Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Mellow Penelo 's Beta Reader Profile
action: Send Message . Subscribe . Favorite
profile: p Member Profile
email: Email
since: 07-11-02, id: 231394
web: Homepage
Author has written 2 stories for Dragon Ball Z, and Naruto.
β : Mellow Penelo is a registered beta reader and is currently accepting beta reading requests.
Beta Description
Beta Bio: general description as a beta reader
I'll help with spelling, grammar, plot ideas, story lines, planning, all that jazz. Basically what a beta dose.

A warning: I'm can be picky with the content in the stories I beta. I personally think that betas do the best work when they read a story they enjoy.

However, I won't hold your hand and say you can do no wrong because I like your story. Betas don't do that! We're here to help you and maybe make your story greater. I'll tell you when something needs work, give you a fresh point of view, and help you connect with the reader.

No whining or getting offended! If I don't point out something before it's posted, a flamer will. So hear it from someone who wants your story to succeed, your beta. But defend your point, convert me to your side. As a beta, I'm your critic, your reader and your audience. If I'm still iffy on something, either take my advice or don't. It's your story! I certainly won't take anything personal, so don't you either.

My general style is to use the quick and easy DocX feature on this site. I'll make the connection after you've contacted me. Confirm it and send over your first chapter.

I'll anecdote it in red, purple, whatever color font. I'll anecdote on everything from making little comments, such as "Clever!" "I'm confused." "ooh, I like that line.", to little questions, like "Why'd he do that?" "Would Vegeta really do that?"

And you don't need to answer those questions, that's just me wondering. I assume you'll answer them as the story progresses. However, If you think it should be obvious, then it might not have been clear in your writing. Those notes are just to let you know what the reader thinks immediately and if that's the reaction you wanted. Know what I mean?

At the end of the chapter all make more notes, try to explain any problems I had with the story, tell you what I really liked, basically review the whole thing. Then I'll send it back to you. You'll delete the comments as you read them, find them helpful or not. Take my suggestions, or not. If you do change something based on my suggestion, fell free to send the changed document back to me and I'll look over it again. We can do this as many times till your satisfied with your story. It's all about you.

If you have another style, if you don't want me making anecdotes, just tell me. We can proceed however you like.

In the end, I'm hoping we'll both improve our skills. I'm a agreeable person, laid back and friendly.


You can IM me on AIM (MellowPenelo) or send me a PM. If you're not sure what exactly to say, fill this out.

Fandom: (Naruto!)
Title: ( you know)
Rating: (K-> M)
Short(or long)synopsis: (whatever your story's about)
Pairing:(None, Hitomi/Dilandau, Shika/Saku, random Sakura pairings, you get it)
What you need help with:(characters, writer's block, basic editing, etc)
length of story: (oneshot, 5 chapters plus, no idea, etc)

This should help us both, but feel free to ignore it and do your own thing. I'm pretty flexible. ^-~
My Strengths: beta, writing, or reading strengths
Characters. I think I have a good hold on what Kishimoto's characters will do and what they won't do. However, if you want Sasuke to be all smiles and sunshine, kissing babies and handing out chocolates and money, I'll help you get him there. Canon is to be respected, it is not doctrine. We are writers, the gods of our worlds. Nothing is impossible. (In short, I support crack!)

Beside that, I think I'm pretty well rounded with action scenes, emotion and dialog.

Got an OC? I'll help you avoid the dreaded Mary-sue.
My Weaknesses: beta, writing, or reading weaknesses
Sentence structure, I have a habit of starting them with the word "but".
Probably how biased I am in choosing my stories, however if you're really dedicated to your stories, I'll help you out.
Preferred: types of entries I prefer over others
Naruto is my preferred Fandom, but any series I have checked.
Romance, just a iota will have me holding on.
I love crack pairings, Sakura/Anyone especially.
I adore all Akatsuki members, especially paired with Sakura - but not necessary.
Team centered fics (any team).

If you're not sure if your stories fall into these categories, contact me anyway! I'll see what I can do. ^-^
Would Rather Not: types of entries I do not want to beta for
Yaoi.
Yuri.
Hinata centric fics (she bores the hell out of me)
Pure smut.
Time travel.
High school fics.
Poetry.
Shika/Tem has to be the only pairing I really hate.
Sakura/Neji, probably the only guy I get bored with.
Come to think of it, I steer clear of the Hyuugas.
Beta Preferences
Language: English
Content Rating: Fiction K » M
Categories: categories in black are ones this beta has authored for
Anime » Bleach
Anime » Castle in the Sky
Anime » Cat Returns
Anime » Dragon Ball Z
Anime » Escaflowne
Anime » Howl's Moving Castle
Anime » Inuyasha
Anime » Last Exile
Anime » Naruto
Anime » Ranma
Anime » Rurouni Kenshin
Anime » Spirited Away
Anime » Trigun
Cartoon » X-Men: Evolution
Genres: genres in black are ones this beta has authored for
General
Romance
Humor
Drama
Adventure
Fantasy
Family
Friendship
Return to Top