:'( My feeeeeeelz!

The worst decision he would ever have to make.

wow...

A wonderful story that had me feeling quite sad by the end. Beautifully written, I salute you're ability! If only they had thought of this in canon... Wouldn't have made for much a movie though...

Vithian

Oh my God. This... Oh my God! I cannot believe... Yoda? And Obi-Wan? Maybe Palpatine was right about the Jedi... Molto Bene, you have successfully shocked the bejeebers out of me. This is the most moving fic I have ever read. Congratulations. I might just go curse the Jedi Order now, but well done.

charliebrown1234

You did such a good job! I was trying so hard not to cry, but it was wonderful! : )

I don't know what should I write about it. The most revered and respected Jedi Masters from the Council plus sentence of death for innocent child. Anakin did nothing wrong yet!

And all these LIES. Anakin had trust for his Master. He believed in his words. He knew something is wrong, but he rolled his sleeve up... /sniff sniff/ Because he loved Obi Wan.

I hope all Jedi will be punished for it. The Force created Anakin, he had his destiny, now it is nothing.

The don't know who Sidious is, but THEY DO KNOW Anakin will be Jedi Order's death, really?

Easy solution, yeeeeaaaa, kill the teenager and everything will be okay...

I want congratulate You for Your idea for this story. It's powerful. I was reading it many times. Maybe You should write sequel for it?

Poor Anakin. I dislike Windu and Yoda. I feel sorry for Kenobi. He should'nt agree for his Padawan's death!

Damned Jedi Code.

No... what is it? I can't stop reading! Your story is wonderful, but - it is not a Jedi way! Anakin is a child! He did nothing wrong. He trusted his Master. Poor boy...I don't understand Obi Wan, I disagree with Yoda and Windu...

It's very strange: all these visions were about Anakin. Jedi Masters - JEDI MASTERS! - found a solution - death penalty for innocent child. I want ask about Darth Sidious, what with him?

He is Sith Lord, he is quilty NOW. Naboo's blockade, Qui Gon's death, evil plots and schemes.

If Palpatine's FATE was death from the Vader's hands... What happens next? Lord Vader does'nt exist...I am very curious...

I hope You understood my weak English. I want congratulate You. Maybe You should write a sequel?

Poor Ani. He trusted his Master. He was innocent. This was'nt Jedi Way! Echchch...

*Sob.* They killed a child. No matter how "necessary," Anakin was still a beautiful, lovable child. The real tragedy in all this is that, for all their insight into the future, Yoda, Mace, (and Obi-Wan) could not pierce the present to find the true

"architect of it all," Darth Sidious.

;_;

What a way to rip someones heart out

Despite being fairly certain that I read this on the Dead Padawan Society, today was the day to reread it. Obi-Wan grieved and then went on in this chilling AU, releasing his vow to Qui-Gon (and good for him that he acknowledged his anger over the council chamber abandonment scene).

omg!obi wan how could you? very sad but nice.

that is so sad, i think i'm gonna cry...

you killed Himm "sob" your evil but somehow i knew it was coming and i agree with Wuff ya just dont kill childeren cause theyre dangerouse. good writing but bad plot

That was shocking. Outright shocking. I sat reading this and my heart was hammering in my chest. I really hoped for another ending... You're a good writer, really.

BUT there's no way I can agree with what happened. It's just wrong to kill a child. Plainly and simply wrong. It's always wrong, no matter the consequences. Calculating with human lives is wrong. Always. And saying that there was no other choice...well, what does it say about the idea of humanity that is behind such a statement? It claims people cannot change, i.e. they are practically nothing else but programmed robots... And isn't that the point of Star Wars? That people CAN change? That there is not just good and evil? And even Darth Vader in his evilness could finally change back to his good former self?