Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Elven Song - Page 1 of 54
TheSoliloquy
2009-08-28 . chapter 2
I loved it! Really brought tears to my eyes. Coincidentally I was listening to a sad song in iTunes at the times, so that added to it :)
artgirl
2009-08-05 . chapter 15
sigh i love this story, this is my second time reading it.A very unique story. I am very happy this plot bunny chased you down! You are a great writer and portray the lotr characters well, which is a real accomplishment when you compare your self to most of the writers on . Great job.
saxgirl42
2009-05-14 . chapter 15
I must admit I was... dubious about reading this at first. I have witnessed my fair share of bad death fics, believe me.

However, I must say that you pulled it off quite well! I enjoyed the subtle way you incorporated the stages of grieving into the story, and the plot was well thought-out and not rushed. Your characters were pretty spot-on, and I absolutely adored the epilogue. Altogether, you did a fantastic job, so thanks for the great read! I really enjoyed myself. :)
Expecting Rain
2009-04-23 . chapter 15
Oh my gosh! This is a wonderful story, and I don't know why I hadn't read it before now! Oh wow, what can I even say about this? Your depictions of grief were very accurate, your characters were wonderfully in character, your plot kept me guessing but I wasn't confused... You are amazing.
ceDes
2009-04-03 . chapter 4
and this chapter made me cry yet again! why and how dare you put me through such pain to see my dear legolas die? lol
ceDes
2009-04-03 . chapter 3
omG! you are so horrible... lol.. YOU MADE ME CRY! lol... i love legolas! -__-... he cant be dead! DEAD! NO! lol
Ohtar Vicky
2009-03-22 . chapter 15
Wa! You killed him! *sobs*
But then u brought him back to life again so its ok!
:D Great story!
V*
L.A.H.H.
2008-12-21 . chapter 15
Well, now I've finished all of them. What am I supposed to do now! It was wonjderful, I loved it. And all your portrayals of characters.
Rebell
2008-11-11 . chapter 2
Wow... I'd read this a couple of years ago, and when I saw it in the archives, I remembered it being so amazing I thought I'd reread it. And yay, am I glad I did!

Truly spectacular mellon-nin. This is one of the few stories that can reduce me to sniffles, and you do it so well! Wonderful plot line, fabulous descriptions, amazing characterizations... and I haven't even gotten past the second chapter yet! I do seem to remember though, that our lovely elf comes back to life after some trials, so I must keep this in mind... even as I sniffle while I read these next chapters...

Do you have a big head from flattery yet? I hope so, you deserve it! :D
kateydidnt
2008-09-26 . chapter 9
"Grief is much like water, Gimli son of Glóin. Trapped it becomes stagnant and sour; only when released can it remain pure."

That is truly one of the BEST metaphors for grief I have ever seen. Bravo for beautiful wording andsentiment.
bleedingkansas
2008-07-25 . chapter 15
Oh god. Short as it is, this is probably my favorite part of the entire fic! :3 So touching! I congratulate you on a job well done with this fic. :D
bleedingkansas
2008-07-25 . chapter 10
Holy Jesus, I might have cried if you killed him again. I certainly came close the first time around! D:

*scurries back to read*
GoodnessKnows
2008-06-02 . chapter 10
Great story! Out of all your characters, I especially like your interpretation of Galadriel. She's one of those very removed characters in LotR, but you do a very good job in portraying her grief.

It strikes me as I read this that in most Legolas-centric fanfics I read, Thranduil's on the verge of having a heart attack the whole time. Poor guy; and just because we like our angst, too.
Martiny the one and only still
2008-04-22 . chapter 15
This story made me cry sevral times, and I ruined my homework =( But its readable...somewhat (like all my writing...) then people were bothering me...and I was hiding I was crying, it was not fun! But...it was worth it! Write a new one soon!
cereajeb
2008-02-03 . chapter 5
WHA...WHAT? I THOUGHT HE WAS DEAD! TRICKY WENCH!

*is still ranting* here you had me balling my eyes out (they actually HURT, you know) and he wasnt even dead! that, missie, was pure evil of you! i do feel sorry for legolas' mother, though :(

well, at least i know why the story is so long now...
Return to Top