Admiral Lily 2008-10-11 . chapter 1What I wouldn't give to see a continuation of this particular story. To watch as father trained the unknowing son. To see them develop and bond and everything. But I also see how this story could be complete. A new beginning with the future unwritten and full of possibility. Wonderful job. |
Vader's Fallen Angel 2008-10-03 . chapter 1A nice, realistic AU. I glad that Anakin and Luke are together. But poor Padme and Leia. And the younglings speculation was accurate. Children will talk and those would be the things they would say.
Nice,
VFA |
Kelev 2008-03-08 . chapter 1This is so sad...but I think it's very good at the same time. Very fitting, and you wrote everyone just the way they ought to be. (So kudos to you, because not many people get it right! LOL)
Perhaps you could post a challenge on your profile so that others could make their own little oneshot follow up to this? It's just a suggestion, in case you decide not to write a sequel of your own to this. |
Amazon101 2007-07-30 . chapter 1 The story itself is absolutely excellent. You misspelled "absence" in the summary, though. |
Smoltenica 2007-07-27 . chapter 1Oh, that was beautiful! Completely AU of course, but wonderful and... I'm sorry, I don't think I can write a coherent review at the moment. But thankyou, that was beautiful! |
Erentei Lord of Insanity 2005-12-02 . chapter 1Hm! An excellent story. I doubt you will continue, but I will fave your account so I can check occasionally. |
Hieiko 2005-08-12 . chapter 1Aww... sad and sweet, and very touching. |
FORCEUSER5 2005-07-29 . chapter 1 plz update soon! I love it so far, but I want to know why the jedi had Luke instead of living with his family.
PLZ UPDATE SOON! |
shloki 2005-07-08 . chapter 1Great story, UPDATE! |
heartnut 2005-07-06 . chapter 1Oh. Interesting AU here. I hope to read more like it-it would make an interesting saga. You've left it nicely, though. Just enough for the reader to use their own imagination. Good job. |
Spyke Raven 2005-07-03 . chapter 1Oh wow. I love this story to so many pieces. I love the entire universe you've depicted in this one slice-of-life. This is who Anakin Skywalker could have been - pilot, husband, loving father and unsure new master. I wish so very much that little Luke had really had the chance to know this man as his father. Thank you so much for writing this. |
chopsticks 2005-06-30 . chapter 1Right, so, I have the feeling this is a story that will never be finished. In fact, you may have never intended for it to be more than this.
I admire that.
Also, my only reaction is "holy beautiful writing." Just beautiful.
I absolutely love it. I have no criticisms of this at all. Just... damn.
You're very talented, and this is such a gorgeous piece of fic. It's such a unique twist on well, everything. The references to the canon make it feel like it could have actually happened (unlike with some AUs where it just goes completely away from everything, including canon), rather than what actually did at the end of RotS (Yes, I know you wrote it beforehand. It's just more poignant reading it afer RotS!).
I've rambled enough here.
Lovely, lovely, lovely! |
FORCEUSER5 2005-06-24 . chapter 1 i like it so far, its really interesting! plz update soon! |
Jessica Skywalker 2005-06-18 . chapter 1Wow!! That's shocking. Does Anakin or Luke know they family thou? Please contiune on I want see what happen. |
FORCEUSER5 2005-06-09 . chapter 1 plz update soon, I really like it so far!! |