 aznpryd 12/28/03 . chapter 1 Well written. Bitter yet sweet. so sad! i really liked how you caught a scene from the movie and wrote the fic. it reminded me that merry and pippin were horrified but they stil did draw their swords and tried to fight the orcs. _ wai boromir was so determined .. too bad he died _ sniff. i like i like :D |
 Daisy Brambleburr 5/3/03 . chapter 1 Wonderful! That was good for a first fic.
I enjoyed it very much, the characters were perfect and I always like to read Boromir fics. You certainly got him spot on!
Nice work,
Love Daisy |
 Aboriginal 1/20/03 . chapter 1 Bohemian
That was a very well put together fic, I enjoyed it a lot. I think you did an excellent job catching Boromir's character and holding on to it. There was one minor mistake, it was one of those where you're thinking of one word but push the wrong key. But other than that it was really good. Bravo, I can't wait to read more.
Thanks for your time,
Aboriginal |
 sweetcatastr0phe 12/31/02 . chapter 1very touching. i never much liked boromir. i'm not entirely sure why. but this shows him in a different light. a much more likable light. |
 Morgan Le Faye 12/23/02 . chapter 1 *sniff* *sniff* oh that was too sad! Great work. :) |
 Sammia Took 12/21/02 . chapter 1Awww! I liked this! I love Boromir, Merry, and Pippin! Very VERY VERY Cute! *sobs* My poor babies! *huggles all three* Good Job! |
 Starfleet Hobbit 12/20/02 . chapter 1Waaaaaa! My poor precious! That was so sad! Well, I guess if you're a Boromir fan sadness comes with the territory. Great story! |
 TK The Tenacious 12/20/02 . chapter 1 Storm? I used to read you Moulin Rouge fanfiction! I can't beleiave you write here to! Loved this story, it's beautiful. A nice relfection on everything. Friendships, hobbits etc. I liked it alot. :D
TK |
 Dia 12/19/02 . chapter 1 Awww... poor Boromir. I must say I never liked him much, but you make him almost likeable. But you're just good like that.
Aragorn's still my man. *clutches him posessively*
Short, true, but very, very good. |
 Imprisoned in Cork 12/19/02 . chapter 1Ooh my gosh what a good story. It's soo sad. Just saying how good your story is.
Bye |
 The Phantom 12/19/02 . chapter 1Ah, Storm darling, finally a piece of LOTR work from you. It could only have been a matter of time...
Lovely reflections from the son of Gondor. Ruminations before death are always a tricky thing, but I think you captured them smoothly.
He did admire the Hobbits; you can see it in his eyes every time he looks at them. I could hear his voice speaking to me through this story, and that was an excellent feeling.
Bravo, bravo, hope to see more LOTR from you! :)
Phantom
(PS - HI!) |
 Kate 12/19/02 . chapter 1 This was a great story, really touching. i love interaction between boromir and the hobbits, and this was a really good look at boromir's death. good job! |
 Treasure Planet Girl 12/18/02 . chapter 1 Interesting. it is short but sweet and to the point. this was a pretty good story, maybe if it would have been his thoughts for the WHOLE movie. just a thought @- |