u did a wonderful job, I love it so far... Im finna keep reading.

nice

Absolutely lovely! I liked the lighter atmosphere you managed to impart to a good chunk of this story. It was very well balanced between the angst the drama and the humor. I adore Sirius in his role as a professor and I am so glad I stumbled upon you as an author!

Til the next tale!

galimeril ;D

The first chapter is really odd and a little off putting. The whole time, I was asking, "Why didn't the Dursleys freak out at the man's connection to magic the instant he mentioned knowing James Potter?" but I really do want to keep reading so I'll go ahead now

Love the story, it has all the elements of good fanfiction. There's a plot, humor, action, and in characterness. In most long fanfics, I haven't been able to feel the essence of creativity or the story pull. Can't even explain how well you've written it.

-Theawsomecheesemistres

wow - just, omg wow... i love your writing style and the detail you go into in setting things up, without losing focus is awesome... if its ok with you, can i use your story as a reference? i'm writing a GW/HP xover and am a little stuck on how the battles and verbal spars need to play out later in the story and you seem to know exactly how to word them to keep readers coming!

now off to keep reading (and later raid your other stories and favs _)

hey man finished the story. But i was a little dissapointed. i expected some epic battle. i liked broken promises and that series better. but i came back to this chapter cuz i liked it best

dude, im loving your stories. really i do. but this one was a little gay. you gota stop so much emotion. it makes your story enthralling but your laying it on a little thick. remus holds sirius from BEHIND? thats a bit gay dude. i cant imagine them diong that in the movies.

lmfao! hahahaha omg dude that made me laugh my fucking ass off! it was sooo freaking funny! jeez even reading it made me laugh, never mind if it was a motion picture! lmao hahahhaahahaha o man you just made my day with this chapter

Oh my gosh, I wasn't gonna review until the end, but...That was the funniest thing I've read in a long time. I. Can't. Breathe. Laughing too damn hard!

Thank you!

I realize this is an older fic. It's one of the first I ever read. Do oyu have any idea how much I loe it?

I have spent the last day & a half reading this story like a woman addicted and I have literally JUST finished! Completely brilliant! Parts of it were even better than the original - the destruction of Beauxbatons gave me chills! It's made me want to reread the entire series again!

After checking your profile, I saw that you never actually got round to writing the sequel which is a tremendous shame. However I do understand that since it's not been forthcoming in the last 7 or so years, it is hugely unlikely it will ever be written, so I'm not going to ask after it.

I intend on starting "Promises Unbroken" as soon as I can tomorrow, so you may well be hearing from me again over that lol. Until then though, I'm going to go to sleep!

Dinny

xxx

Short note, because this wonderful story kept me up two hours past when I meant to go to bed, and two and a half hours past when I should have gone to bed: this was fantastic, I forever love your Sirius Black, Severus Snape, and Albus Dumbledore as perfect depictions of very complicated but noble-at-heart people, and this story was a pleasure to read.

Great story.

Oh my word, that was too funny!