This is excellent! Please update!

I adore this story! the friendships between the fellowship really shine through and i love the way Gimli & Legolas argue. Everyones really in character and i'm so glad that i'm not the only one to have noticed Aragorn's split personalities. I realise this story hasn't been updated since '05 and that you've probably abandoned it but if you ever decide to update or if you need a beta let me know because i'd be happy to help.

Sezza.

I. AM. SPEECHLESS.

With wonder. And awe. And...and, oh gods of wolves and demons, I love Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli's friendship, it is so heartbreakingly beautiful and you showed it right here in the end and I...I...

Please continue this. For my sake if not yours. You haven't updated in years, but you have a lot of talent in keeping everyone in character and that's difficult enough on a usual basis without adding the challenges by a crossover as well.

I loved the last part of this chapter. Absolutely loved it. I haven't adored a fanfic like this in a long, long time. Please tell me you're going to finish this someday. Please. Or at least reply and tell me you've discontinued this, so that I don't need to keep hoping. You're so talented it hurts...

I'm quite indulgent when it comes to crossovers. I've read few Lord of the Rings crossovers, since my focus is mainly on Naruto/Harry Potter, but I chanced across yours and I have fallen completely in love. Do keep up the good work, and I understand that life has been very demanding, but surely in the past six years you could have cut out some time to continue this?

Many thanks for sharing this story with everyone,

Qi Okami

you have a really incredible fanfiction here. wonderful plot line, excellent characters,really hilarious dialogue, and a great sense of when to switch POV'S and what view to tell the story by. I love how all the wizards think of the LOTR folk and especially legolas's character is fun to listen to! i think its a little weird that their just telling everyone but thats the only problem i can see in the entire story(and such a minor one at that!) I cant wait for the wizards to see legolas in his real form, and realize he's mmune to spells, maybe in the next chapter uring the fight?Also the LOTR folk could show them some of their memorize in a pensive? to prove they've fought against evil before or something like that. anyways please update! this is a great fic and it would be a shame to just end it, especially on a cliffie!(man thats down right diabolical...i should consider doing it some times*laughs evilly*)please please please with a chocolate chip cookie on top?(because why would you want a cherry when chocolate is so much better?) Just a request, its a great story and good LOTR crossovers are hard to find, consider! good luck:)

GR! DIE! No wait... DON'T DIE! If you do I'll never know what happens. Instead, UPDATE or I will so very distrubing things to you which may or may not include voodo rituals, plot bunnies and tribbles... ! *evil glare of DOOM! TM*

great story. keep writing

This story is absolutely wonderful. It's so difficult to find good crossovers, and this is definitely one of them. Everyone is in-character, the plot is interesting, and you have a plausible explanation for the Fellowship (and the others) being there. I also have to say that I absolutely love Legolas. He acts just like how I would imagine him too. Infuriating, playful, but with a serious and noble aspect as well.

I realize this hasn't been updated in several years, but even if you have abandoned it, I just wanted to let you know that this is a truly wonderful story you have going.

Maddie,

Alright. Lets just get one thing clear anf out of the way before I go off on my little rant-I love this fic. I mean, its great and plausible and the characters aren't OOC at all and the dialouge between Legolas and Gimli is just...just WONDERFUL.

Got that? Ok, now lets continue.

You haven't updated since (checks quickly)2005. 06-24-05, to be precise. AND you left a cliffie! I mean, not updating by itself for three years is bad enough, but with a CLIFFIE? That's just cruel. And its not like you've dropped off the face of the earth or something. I mean, you've updated your profile and all that. Have you discontinued it? Because if you have, plz tell me. Us. Whatever.

And, again, just in case youre offended by this (not my intention at all) if this fic wasn't one of the best I've read for a while, I wouldn't be bothering.

Anxiously,

The Tolkien-Geek

Bother. I just found this story and was enjoying it immensely, when I suddenly got to the last chapter up and discovered the story had stopped cold. Is there any chance that there are more chapters elsewhere? I would really like to see what happens next, and I don't often say that about LoTR crossovers.

I read them in hopes of, as I did this time, finding one that was well written and internally consistent. Generally I am greatly disappointed.

Even though it's been three years since your last posting, I sincerely hope you find the inspiration to take up this story again.

um ok so i see you havent updated for like three years but i am going to talk to you anyway :D

first of all, is the dark ball a palantir?

next, the moment between frodo and aragorn (about the first time they met) had me in stitches (yes, i realize that wasnt in this part)

finally, i like how you've done the set up...with them reincarnated as opposed to magicaly ending up in hogwarts

are you going to finish this story? have you planned it all out? if you have, and you dont intend to finish it, could you message me with how it ends? random request, i know, but i really really like this story

This is an amazing of all,it makes sense!perfect sense!You also made the characters interact very my opinion,not one person was out of character.I was hoping that Harry would meet the Fellowship sooner,but it doesnt been hoping for a cross-over between LotR & HP,and have found ,most of them are portrayed the Fellowships friendship very well!Gimli and Legolas's bantering is very good!ARRGH! What is going to happen?Is the Fellowship going to whip out respective weapons and do some Death Eater bashing!When will all the students belive that they are reincarnated!Cant wait till next chappie!

chocolatebookworm

P.S-I have no constructive is already brilliant! Ahem...I'm going away so I dont start ranting abou how amazing this is...

Aw... That's it? Is this story dead? I hope not, because it's actually a surprisingly original crossover. Please update, or at least do something with the idea.

Wow. I was bored and re-reading some of my old favorite stories and then started to read the review's This story was suggested so I thought what the heck. Good job. You have my attention and my "adding"

I like the story so far. You should continue it. One tiny question though: Is Boromir going to die again? Having left your story with a cliffhanger for about two years, why don't you finish it. I really do like it. Also, I'd like to hear about Boromir and Aragorn teaching. Those two might kill each other first. :-} Not many suggestions, I know. Just want you to pick up this excellent story.

TWO YEARS! How could you seemingly abandon such an amazing story? I always love the reincarnated crossover type stories - this is the second one i've read. And you had to end it with a cliffie! *wails to the sky*