Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Im Melin Le: I Love You
Sunsetcheetah 2003-03-04 . chapter 1
Oh great.

Now I’m crying and I have to go read a sappy stupid Mary-sue in order to control myself.

You are such a good writer! No scratch that, Excellent writer more like it!

This was such a bittersweet fic and I enjoyed it,
(Even though I started crying (dang the month))

Either way, please continue writing and please continue on with the story 'Tale of an Orc'!!

Also thanks for reviewing my little story! ^_^
I was so honored you even took the time too look at it much less read it! Thank You So Much!!

Keep this up!!

Check ya later CAtz!!
Cirdan 2003-02-05 . chapter 1
Your Celebrian's nice. And Elrond, trying not to weep before his lady, was a great touch. I could really associate with Celebrian's bit about how it is a child's duty to visit her parents. (Very Asian.) And, of course, Elladan (and Elrohir and Arwen to a lesser extent) were cute little Elflings.
Jenn 2003-01-24 . chapter 1
Nice little pair of vignettes - captures the joy and sorrow of the family in a succinct way. I like your choice to use Elladan as a sort of viewing glass. It creates an intimacy that an anonymous third person's view would not.
WatcherChild 2003-01-24 . chapter 1
Thank you, Casey!!!

Elladan is so sweet here - I can picture a tiny Elfling holding his mother's hand and protecting her from the trees!

That Elladan should suffer so much is understandable, and you have portrayed his grief so well!!! This is a lovely fic, and it's such a wonderful birthday present! Thank you!
Hellga 2003-01-24 . chapter 1
Very nice short story. And it soothes my heart to see someone using correct Elvish. I was going to comment on Namarie, but you are too smart for me and you put the explanation in the note at the end. My sincere applause :) *hug*
Soledad (too lazy to log in) 2003-01-24 . chapter 1
Awww, that was so sweet at the beginning and so sad at the end! Poor Elladan - no wonder be's become obsessed with huning Orcs after his mother left.
Dragon Confused 2003-01-24 . chapter 1
Nice story. I liked this.

:)
Bakasaru 2003-01-23 . chapter 1
oooo....nice story..... very touching. and you know your elvish well.
Return to Top