Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: In Mandos

Nessa Ar-Feiniel
2004-03-24
ch 1,
abusekeep going on this
Klose
2003-01-31
ch 1,
abuseOh, that was eerie. A few mistakes (tense, grammar). The dialogue was very interesting. And the introspection was simply billiant. Imagery is a tough tool to use, but you've done well... I am utterly freaked out. :P
Woman of the Dunedain
2003-01-31
ch 1,
abuseYippee! Mandos is incredible!
Mouse
2003-01-29
ch 1,
abuse"I read." ;)

Very beautiful, in a strange and mystical sort of way. I like her conversations with Mandos in particular, the questions that she answers "No!" to each time. Flinch-worthy dream(?) scene when she "becomes" Feanor at Losgar. And love the poetic thrill in the line "she searches for God". What *does* she look for, ultimately? What does she hope to accomplish in finding Feanor?
Lovely and unnerving overall.
Cirdan
2003-01-28
ch 1,
abuseInteresting. I think it works because they are in Mandos, so the disassociated feeling matches fairly well. Miriel and Nerdanel, they really did need to chat. Nienor? Turin's sister? I suspect you meant Nienna. But nice little story. Especially like: Have him answer your questions. He will. :)
Deborah Judge
2003-01-27
ch 1,
abuseAh, I prefer beauty over clarity any day. And so I like this story very much. A little tricky to figure out in the beginning, but worth it by the end. Love the idea of Nerdanel talking to Miriel, and the conclusions they come to.
Maeve Riannon
2003-01-27
ch 1,
abuseI like this story. Your picture of Miriel weaving hate is chilling. And weirdness becomes you! :)
Return to Top