Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Fall - Page 1 of 4
(the) thing
2008-03-12 . chapter 1
*Applaudes enthusiasticaly*
Well done! I can sort of indentify with her, nice twist, and very good ending!
miriamne
2007-10-02 . chapter 1
great story! it was nice to finally see an "arranged marriage" story that showed that even though the guy was great and would treat her gently and cherish her, an arranged marriage is an arranged marriage and maybe not wanted. this is the first story i've seen like this. Yes, it's sad, but it has another truth to it. The truth of wanting, as Eowyn said, to not be in a cage. Even if your companion in that cage with you was great.
Nieriel Raina
2007-07-21 . chapter 1
oh how horribly sad! This is very good, though bitter. Not all stories should have a happy ending so this is refreshing.

NiRi
OBSESSEDWITHLOTR
2007-02-02 . chapter 1
Oh that was just horrible! But brilliant!
Caitlin
2006-06-15 . chapter 1
oh...my...gosh... This was such a well written story! I really really enjoyed reading it. It would even be great if you continued it and made it into an actual story instead of just a one-shot. Just an idea.

Honestly though.. This was fantastic!
Isabel
2005-07-08 . chapter 1
O...M...G! That was just super awsome! Wow My mouth was hanging open at the end that was just beuatiful! alrightwell you saved my day! love love love love this story ! you have a great writting mind!
Special K3
2005-03-20 . chapter 1
I really love this story, so sad and touching. I think it is amazing to put so much emotion in such a short story. great work!
jo4
2005-02-18 . chapter 1
i like your prose. it's beautiful and yes, the twist is good.
ScottishYem
2005-01-30 . chapter 1
Bravo! Encore! Please? You can do it! Don't hide your talent from the hungry reader!! Lol. But, do whatever you want. You probabaly WON'T be writing more in this story, but I just want to let you know that it was great. So...Bravo!
SY
majcarter
2005-01-21 . chapter 1
oh that is such a good story. I LOVE IT!!
dreamalittledream
2004-06-19 . chapter 1
great story. short. really short. yet full of meaning and emotions. well done! by the way, are you going to have a sequel to "in wonderland"? i hope you are. well...most people hope so, i guess.
Believe in the Light
2004-03-19 . chapter 1
Well, my name doesn't really fit the story does it? To tell the truth, I find it an immensely touching story, full of sadness... Perhaps she could become happy...well, that is what I'll imagine... or not. This is a truly great story even without the "and they lived happily ever after". You create in the reader a feeling of such compassion and sadness... it's amazing. My only regret: that the end could not be happier.
Pimpelipom
2004-02-22 . chapter 1
Oh, this is great! I love the melancholy feeling of this. Great how you don't make her have a angsty or abusive past or any such rot. It is magnificent, how there is really nothing to be sad about, how she understands this and it makes her despair even more. The best tragedy is to be found in the lack of it, I always thought. I must say this is my favourite LotR-fic this far.
Nethien
2004-02-20 . chapter 1
that was amazing! i loved it! keep writing :)
~Mellon
Soccer-Bitch
2004-01-24 . chapter 1
this was a really good short story. usually i dont like short stories, but this one is really good. laterz.
Return to Top