 a vestige of peace 2009-05-25 . chapter 1You know what? I really liked that! The idea behind it and the potential was brilliant, but- i know, there is a but, but u did ask for suggestions- I think some parts should be tweeked a little for maximum emotional impact. Like, when he says "Harry", I think it should be Potter, because Draco Malfoy's character is emersed in formalities and regardless of how he feels about the war- Potter will always be Potter to him. And the musings- both Harry's and Draco's, I think should be contracted. You have something very emotional to say, but you over explain it sometimes. sometimes a single sentence would have done fine, but you have added an extra one. Like:
"The wind slashed through his hair. His manoeuvres were death-defying...
He contemplated death..." If you took out "his manoevers were death-defying..." it would make the statement following leave more of an impact. |
 goatheart 2007-12-07 . chapter 1I'm impressed. I like the dimension you added to Malfoy's character it makes you look at him in a completely different light. Good work! |
 broken.wings. 2005-02-21 . chapter 1 I never thought of Draco that way...it's very interesting. Good job. |
 Werecat99 2004-06-22 . chapter 1I very rarely read angst and/or anything with the Boy-that-lived in it, but I liked that.
At the beginning the story seemed as another H/D angst stories, but the last paragraph produced a very different angle the I liked. Unusual, to say the least, and this means a lot when it comes to HP fanfiction.
One note, though, regarding the formatting. I'm not sure how well bold and underlined text works in a story. But again this might be a completely personal thing, so feel free to ignore me.
Again,
thanks for the reviews. |
 EveningStar (Linnea) 2004-06-01 . chapter 1 Whoo! It's Morbane! Oddly enough I just stumbled across this without looking for your account. I really like this Morbane my dear, it was very sad though...I hate Harry being a helpless symbol. Like a modern day Joan of Arc really. *Muses* Yes...very sad. |
 Liebling 2003-06-08 . chapter 1I really liked it...
It was just super odd.
Great job either way =)
~Mel |
 Jedi Tess of Gryffindor 2003-05-14 . chapter 1 I'm impressed! This is really original, and i must add that i'm quite glad you didn't try to make a romance out of this. Perfect! |
 MiZ PuNk 2003-04-22 . chapter 1*a smile slowly spreads onto her face* Lovely story. *grins* It's intresting. Very unusual, I like it, and that fact. It's very refreshing, gives you a different light on things, doesn't it? Beautiful words you chose, you obviously have a penchant for those. *smiles* I like. Off to read more.
~Tricia*)
ps:this popped into my head just now,
"Silly Potter, Kicks are for kids." lol *grins childishly* so sorry, it was taunting me, thought I'd share. ^_^* |
 avapouhi 2003-03-23 . chapter 1 This was very good. And yes, I think it is different from the other stories. I mean, it's not the first time Draco seems to care about Harry, but in here, he doesn't really like him, it's more like he understands him and supports him...without showing it.He is in the good side,but doesn't tell it because Hary needs him to be his enemy.
And I think the codependency between the two really exists. Even if their relationship isn't fully described in the books,there's a strong connection between them. I really hope JK Rowling will do something about this... |
 I Dream2 2003-03-04 . chapter 1I like it.
It seems so . . . realistic. |
 sweetspontaneous 2003-03-03 . chapter 1alright- here's my comment: the second part- the guilt thing and Harry's isolation from his friends- is nothing new, but it's done quite neatly here. the first part is a different story- it's metaphoric, if i'm not reading too much into it, and it subtly suggests that Draco's attitude to the whole thing may not be exactly what it seems to be. the last part is great- interesting take on the good/evil dynamic, without a total departure from character. this is actually quite interesting, certainly not overdone. and anyway, sometimes i think that every possible imaginable plotline or viewpoint for the continuation of these books has been used or warped somewhere. the real question left is whether even JKR is going to be able to come up with something that hasn't already been done. |
 sasori 2003-03-03 . chapter 1oh, that was very nice. good job. although yu could have expanded a bit more.but sweet and short is good. |
 Lucia Dreams 2003-03-03 . chapter 1 Interesting ^^ |
 Miss Black Dragon 2003-03-03 . chapter 1Hmph. I'll review if I want to, and you can't stop me. =P
Anyway. This was.. very. different. Odd. But likable, yes, likable. That's all. |
 Morbane 2003-03-03 . chapter 1Yes, I'm reviewing my own story. Mostly to comment on a problem with it: I'm not sure I'm saying anything new; I think I may simply be rephrasing what others have said. Anyone want to comment on that? Hmm. |