Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Christmas Cheer - Reviews: Page 1 of 2

Muskrat
2005-01-07
ch 1,
abuseGo to hell, moden night. Like you're a fan.
Although it didn't ryhme good it was very original.
I liked how you put it together. Bravo!
dogbertcarroll
2004-11-13
ch 1,
abuseGood story, great omake.
Morden Night
2004-01-24
ch 1, anon.
abuseCarrot Glace I'm VERY disappointed in you! I'm a fan of your fanfiction generally but this christmas one was absolutely TERRIBLE! The night before christmas one STARTED to rhym but then quickly degraded into snesless banter. I couldn't even finish it. It was god awful! I just... I'm very disappointed in you.
Elusion
2002-02-26
ch 2,
abuseHeehee! I'm a little late for the Christmas spirit, but these are cute stories!
Saggit
2002-01-01
ch 1,
abuse"The only thing that bothered a bit was how the Ghost of Christmas Present could possibly be showing Ranma doing anything to Ranma, since technically that would be a paradox. But whatthehell, it's Christmas. ;)"

This is what comes of not reading what you write before submitting it, although I could simply blame my faux pas on the presence of "carrot" in Carrotglace, since everybody knows that carrots are evil. Be that as it may...

What I really meant to write was that Ranma shouldn't be able to view scenes including himself when being escorted by the Ghost of Christmas Present. Especially when those scenes contain actions that are wildly unlikely but never explained.

And no, I'm not dissing this story. I may not like carrots, which are evil, but I do recognize good fiction when I read it, dagnabit. ;)
lija
2001-12-26
ch 2, anon.
abuseHehe...poor Ranma.... Great stories to cheer up after the holidays. :)
Saggit
2001-12-26
ch 2, anon.
abuseWhen I started reading this Ranmaized version of the Christmas Carol I kinda expected the usual fanfic "let's put the cast of Ranma through the usual cheesy Dickenisan paces, maybe throw in Urd, and end with enough Capra-esque sugar to send even Azuza into shock." Thank the gods you opted for a wonderfully sour, rather cynical view of Ranma's world--and I loved the reintroduction of Ryouga at the end. (It never fails to amuse how many creative ways the better fanfic writers find to put that little directional problem of his to use.)

The only thing that bothered a bit was how the Ghost of Christmas Present could possibly be showing Ranma doing anything to Ranma, since technically that would be a paradox. But whatthehell, it's Christmas. ;)
Personal Dreamer
2001-12-25
ch 2, anon.
abuse"I see dead people" LOL that was great the anime ghosts lol but DAM thoughs people for distroying Ranma's life.
neko-chama
2001-12-25
ch 2, anon.
abuseOooooh! Really quite ingenious. I love it.
Daisuke
2001-12-25
ch 2,
abuseThis is a masterprice! Its even better than last years hehe ^_^.
Shea McIntee
2001-12-04
ch 1, anon.
abuseBWA-HA-HA-HA-HA!!!

Love it!
Booksavvey
2001-05-27
ch 1, anon.
abuseI like it. Very funny.
HarmonyAk
2001-05-09
ch 1,
abuseHehehe...I liked "How Ranma Stole Christmas." It rhymes plenty :-) It's also in character. Well done!
Sholio
2001-03-02
ch 1,
abusehehehehe. I love parodies.
Otaku King
2001-01-05
ch 1,
abusei liked the first one...but the second one was kinda lacking....heh heh..ranma's ego's two sizes too big, if you ask me...hehehehehehehehehehehe
Return to Top