Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Beyond Rivendell
amberliz 2003-04-13 . chapter 3
i read a little bit about her in the part you sent me a while ago! i can't wait to see more of her, tho! great chapter!
Kiyomisa 2003-04-07 . chapter 1
Heya! It's pretty good so far. I wasn't sure about an Inu Yasha LOTR x-ver, but you're doing it well ^-^. Meinu's great, keep it up, 'm waiting for the next chapter.
amberliz 2003-03-29 . chapter 2
ah! only a couple more chapters and we'll be at stuff i haven't seen yet! *is excited*
jodancingtree 2003-03-26 . chapter 1
That was fascinating, Jaid Skywalker! A little puzzling -- are these other characters with the Japanese-sounding names out of some other fandom, or your own creation?

Constructive criticism? M -- there are quite a lot of characters being introduced in a short chapter -- hard to keep them straight. Maybe you could let some of them go nameless? I mean, all the elves except Celebden get killed right off, so I didn't need to try & remember their names... maybe you could just name the mother, and let the others be "her husband", "her brother (or servant or whatever)"?

Same with the characters back in the village -- maybe the reader will get to know all of them as the story progresses, but it's kind of like meeting a roomful of people, confusing. Don't mean to be critical, tho' -- I did enjoy it!
amberliz 2003-03-25 . chapter 1
yay! first chapter! great prolouge! yeah it definitely helps that you did some explaining about the youkai, i really liked it!
Iris Omega 2003-03-20 . chapter 1
La la la... you finally posted it! SO HAPPY! ^_^ This is good! I can't wait for you to post more! (especially the parts with Alkiel in it!) I know you have it written, so you better post it soon, or else! Hee hee, I'm not very good at threatening people. I'm just a harmless blonde. *rolls eyes* But I won't be so harmless when we rule America!! (patented evil laugh #3458) BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA! *choke, gasp* Oh well, that didn't work too well. PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE UPDATE SOON! (P.S. Shippo's such a cutie!)
Return to Top