After having read the origional, this one isn't bad but seems to be a bit hurried. Looking forward to your next update. Thanks.

good start! will there be more updates in the future?

when did he get the cane?

kool

That's interesting, cause after reading the original story I wondered how different it would be if no one at Hogwarts had gotten Harry's letter. This was a great start!

Signed,
Kitty McGonagall

Ep. Wow. This is a fantastic beginning to this story. Is there any chance of you finishing this story? Please. I really like your work, and I've been working my way through your page this morning to read the stories I've not gotten to before, and I am a bit disappointed that so many of them are unfinished. I eagerly await you getting a chance to work on them so I can see what happens next. Keep up the good work. Zafaran

knowticed its been a while since you updated this but i really havent had the chance to look at your other stories till now. i like it sad but like it

*sob, sob* You didn't finish the story! You have to finish it so we know what happens to them after not meeting up like they did. Please? *goes down on knees to beg and pray* I will haunt you in your sleep untill you do! Even one chapter will be appreciated.

P.S. I ammend what I said before. NOW I have the full set!

I have to say I like this version just as much as GSFI...can't wait for you to update.

omg i love it. when will you write more? i'm dying to read it. i love gsfi but i also want to find out what happensnext in this story too. please post more soon

Why have you stopped writing this for a year?! We simpily adore it. I can't wait to see how this ends up like Gold and Silver, Fire and Ice! I can't wait for you to update.

Kaydon and Kat

Well, it sertinly is differnt! We're gonna go read the rest,

Kaydon and Kat

this is great! i think you need a bit more harry in it though. but so far im liking it!

oh! I love the wings. =D I really do. I can't wait to see what happens next, and although I think I like GSFI better, this one is also good.

wowo, this is great. Where;'sa the rest of it