Goodness gracious! Why haven't I stumbled on this story before?

This is so great and I wish you write more of this! I like the idea of Minerva and Severus - you know - like together. Basically, because I'm a great fan of their pairing. Is there any chance you'll continue this story or it just simply ends there?

I really look forward to the next chapters. Please write.

Thanks!

ewewewewewewewewew EW! they kissed, ew ew ew

Very interesting story I cant wait to read more please update soon.

Okay, this was interesting. Bit strange around the edges, but interesting. I'll look forward to seeing other work by your. Zafaran

zafaran at fastmail. fm

Yeow. A powerfully written story, and a rather different take on McGonnagal...

Interesting 'interrogation' session end.

Talk about unexpected! How many husbands would send their wives to another man's bed, a YOUNGER man at that!

Kinky! Odd. Beautiful, and strange. Intimate: a story played out in the shadow and light of rooms rather than the corridors of buildings; a drama of single meeting minds rather than over-busy crowd scenes. So very unlike Rowling-writing, which is the highest of compliments, coming from me.

Well, well. A most interesting and logical presentation of Snape’s abandonment of Voldemort. I like your Minerva (sorry, I’m not too fond of Albus, though yours is good; I suppose I have trouble with his ethics, though I can’t imagine what would have been better to do).
I also like this backstory you are developing for the Professor McGonagall we see now, her student days, her love for Tom, her marriage to Albus (a neat thought). I very much like the way you examine canon Minerva so carefully and include all those little details in the backstory. It helps to give a richness to the individual stories you write.
I've just realised this is still a WIP – from your LJ entries, not from the story as posted on FFN. What does that say about my grasp of story structure, I wonder?

Gee, this story (like the rest of the EW) is absolutely gorgeous! Hope to find some more soon...
Renata D.

Wonderful, absolutely wonderful!
I love the way your characterisation makes each character so human - although usually I think of Snape as more...cold blooded...than your portrayal, it works really well in this fic. I also enjoyed the idea of Minerva somehow turning full circle from Tom, to Albus, to Snape...
Sx

Hey. I just saw something that really pissed me off - some one ripped this fanfic off.

An author by the name of 'Sevie's Gurl' took this story and postred it (titled The Green Thingy) with a horrible summary... it has the exact wording yours does and everything, it's the exact same story, and that's not right and completely against the rules.

I thought you ought to know. This is an excellent, amazing fanfic and you deserve all the credit.

Love,

*CEA

(opens mouth, looks about to say something, then closes mouth)

(repeats)

you're a very gifted writer.

the fandom needs more characters to work with.

Oh my gosh! Wow! That is so wonderful! I really like MM/SS more than MM/AD because of ages, but this just so fabulously done! Please continue it! It's just so wonderful, a sequel? Or just more chapters. I'm nearly crying from the sheer emotion in it! Please post more! It's beautiful!

- (meow!)

*blinkblink* Hmm, well, that was interesting. Very unique twist, I admit. I can't help feeling sorry for Dumbledore. It must have hurt so much to have to do that to Snape. *sniffle* I'd like for you to update soon, but I understand if you can't. Bravo on an excellent chapter.