 Velvet Starlight 2009-11-21 . chapter 1That was...incredibly, amazingly cute. Just, really, one of the nicest little lighthearted stories I've ever read. I loved all the hints that were dropped, and the incomprehensibility, and of course the reveal. And just for the record, although it doesn't really need to be said: Sam is too sweet for words. |
 amitai 2008-05-29 . chapter 1This is fantastic! So lovely!
Everyone was so beautifully in character, and it's so *funny*... I knew it was some kind of 'be nice to Josh' thing all the way through, though I wasn't sure what - and the Department of Dimples... *grin* I'd vote for any govt. who promised to create one of them. ^_^
Thank you for this, it's a wonderful, wonderful story.
-amitai |
 whipper 2004-09-12 . chapter 1 How sweet! :) |
 Mirabehn 2004-05-24 . chapter 1Oh that's adorable!
You spin the reader along beautifully, too. I didn't work out what the second "D" stood for until the final paragraph.
Perfect characterisation, lots of Sam which always makes me happy, and an unusually high Charlie and Matt Skinner quotient which is also a plus.
Off to see what else you've written... |
 candleflame 2003-11-21 . chapter 1 what the hell?
i kinda like it
that doesnt mean its not still wierd
dept. of dimples? sam came up with this?
that doesnt seem a little fruity to you?
i dont really care as long as you keep josh happy.
keep up the good(wierd) work |
 Beth Green 2003-11-01 . chapter 1BWWAHAHAHA! 'Department of Dimples,' indeed. With the references to Noel, it wasn't tough to figure out that there was some kind of 'Be nice to Josh' conspiracy going on. Nevertheless, this was very cleverly done, with excellent banter true to the show's better moments. For example, the reference to Matt and Josh discussing things that were just 'a bad idea to try naked.' I don't think I even want to know what sparked that particular conversation. Thanks for sharing this fun read. |
 Glacier-to-be 2003-04-23 . chapter 1(aka Lady Rosethorn)
ok, now that i actually read the last sentence it all comes together! i'm incredibily stupid sometimes. this is incredibly cute! and i loved the tone and the dialogues, and the characters. i liked the slight competition between dona and sam, and that everyone is in on it is really sweet and heartwarming. aw!
will you have more?? |
 slightly so 2003-04-23 . chapter 1i'm intruiged! (spelling!) I want to know more about this club, what exactly do they do? is it all against Josh? oh you have to explain more! |
 Roga 2003-04-18 . chapter 1"Margaret won because, well, spork."
--And that's all there is to it, isn't it? :-)
Heart-warming, kind, and so, so funny. I hope you write more West Wing! |
 Anne11 2003-04-16 . chapter 1What an adorable story! There were so many cute little character touches in this from just about everyone, although I particularly liked that it originated with Sam. (You did miss the obvious "You know, people are starting to realize why you don't date more girls..." crack. :) ) This was a truly innovative plot idea, and your dialogue matched the tone perfectly! I especially liked Josh's silly question about time zones. Made me laugh out loud! As did the choice of code word! Bwah!
I'm going to go look for another of your stories...This was great! Write more soon! |
 Katherine Grace 2003-04-12 . chapter 1*grins* Aw...that's sweet. *laughs* Good for them. |
 Elli 2003-04-12 . chapter 1 Very, very nice. It's such a Sam thing too. Hope to see some more fics from you, hope Sam central, lol. Thanks for sharing! |
 Marianne 2003-04-10 . chapter 1 This is such a sweet story! Really good! |
 Ilmare2 2003-04-09 . chapter 1Brilliant and so funny! Sounds like something the WW staff would do for Josh! I really enjoyed reading this!! |
 epholge 2003-04-09 . chapter 1Are you going to finish, HP and the Fall of Childhood. Please do. I really really love that story. |