This story...i mean wow. it was amazing! really. great job!

i love it! i love slash though! there's so much angst.. i cried when i was reading chapter 11-12 because i thought haldir was actually going to die.. well, i also love Elrond/Erestor finally! they happy for eternity.. keep writing some more fictions though!! i like your fictions..

It started out with such promise!... but then it devolved into banal and lamely written high school angst scenes. And it was the same thing over and over and over. I gave up half way through because it was pretty much the same annoying chapter written over and over and over again. Yawn.

Very angsty. Very nice. Rhyden is deliciously evil; boy, when elves switch sides, they really go all the way, don't they? I am a big Glorfindel/Ecthelion shipper, but this was just so sweet. Your use of flashbacks is excellent, it works well to explain the background without slowing down the story. I really enjoyed reading this.

WOW. THAT WAS WEIRD ok it's 1.10am and i just read that all the bloody way thru and bloody hell that was an odd odd story: HOW many times do ppl die n come back in this?!!? jesus love u need to do a nice one-shot now, u crazy person! great story well done.

Sexy...

Finally! The end! -sob- Yay! First Haldir/Glorfindel fic I've read, and it's definently got me wanting more. Hee! Slashy slashy! Over all a very good story, even though some parts were a bit repetitive. But I loved it still. -happy sigh- I go to read more ficcies now. keep writing or I might have to throw sharp things at you. If you write more, I'll give you cookies! Cookies for you! Write!

This story has always amazed me.

Wow. This story had me spending the whole night awake, trying to finish it before daybreak! THough I failed...;) This is a powerful piece. You so easily lay out the emotions for us, and the emotional intensity had me by the edge of my seat. I mean, wow. The emotional ride was incredible. You had me in tears, and my heart was wrenching in many places. And boy, I love your version of Erestor. I had never seen him portrayed that way before, and it is absolutely delightful. I love all of your characters, plus the story, etc. Thank you for a wonderful story. Please write more fics! I personally dig Legolas/Haldir pairing and think Legolas and ARagorn are REALLY just friends, but your story made me approve of certain Haldir/Glorfindel pairings too. ;) Please continue to write, and excellent job on this fic!

this is so sad! it made me cry! you are doing a wonderful job, keep it up.

HALDIR AND GORFINDEL MURDERER!

*slaps forehead in annoyance*
Not another slash! Puh-leese write something worthwhile.
Do you like, not have any respect at all for the lotr characters? I mean, Glorfindel and Haldir together? Uh, WHAT THE HELL IS THAT ABOUT?
It isn't kool or anything, its sick and wrong! Why do ppl write slashes anyway? They're just like, EWW!

o.0 uhh. ok. freaky. n took a long time i reread it AGAIN. (: nice marn. so sad. wad did Vairye hav to do! n... wad bout Rhyden arhx. o.0 wadeva. it r0x. i cried. AGAIN. u r0x. aww mann. write more! like other stories! one about elrond and erestor! (: ahaha. jia you!

I had just read an extremely sad book and now you make me cry even more. sniff sniff.
But i love it still
Peniel

what can i say? i just spent the last what?? *looks at clock* 7 hours reading this from start to finish. i have NEVER been on such a more emotional roller coaster ride. there were times i was loving you and times i was angry for playing with my emotions like this. of course in the end im loving you LOL. this story was well written, very emotional, very strong in it's power. thank you so much for a wonderful wonderful read! love and light, vesta morgaine