 wigglesfunk 2008-05-17 . chapter 9I cannot believe how great this story was. Your word choice and writing style is so professional and so believable that I didn't want it to ever end. Truly a masterpiece. And the way you wrote the characters of Voldemort and Minerva was spot on! |
 Delilah Anne Marie 2007-12-22 . chapter 9I love Tom/Minerva pairing! There's just so much drama when it comes to them. They could have been so happy in the end if it hadn't been for Tom's destiny. I guess that's why they're such a bittersweet pair.
Wonderful job! :) |
 maxtreme225 2006-07-01 . chapter 9You really should get an award for this peice of fine writing. Not only did you make the story credible to HP fans, you made one that had all the qualities of a strange and wonderful tale! |
 OCDdegrassi 2006-01-22 . chapter 1O! Really good start! |
 mona lisa 2005-08-09 . chapter 9 hi,
oh my god this story is so sad!I am still crying!wonderful!this is the first story in my live which I read and began to cry!I never cried because of a story before!can you please write a second ending for me?I want to be happy again!:-( :-)but thanks for this fascinating story!! |
 xSheshemex 2005-05-07 . chapter 4Very good... |
 SherbetKitty 2005-01-23 . chapter 9Wow... This was so beautiful. This is so on my fave stories list. |
 Jigklotz 2004-08-10 . chapter 9 Whee!! This is the saddest and the most beautiful fic that I've ever read. I've never cried while reading a fic before but I found myself doing it now *duh*
The characterizations are so great and brilliant!
It's a pity that it didn't received more reviews, you really deserved them. Perhaps it was because of the unusual pairing, who would thought eh? McGonagall and Voldemort! I mean, McGonagall has always been my fav character but to have her paired up with Voldemort?! But then again you had made it so believable, that I think I'll become a TMR/MM shipper from now on!
Thanks a lot for writting this wonderful fic, I'll save it to my HD just in case I wouldn't be able to find it again...
Ciao! |
 Allacaya 2004-08-06 . chapter 9Wow!
Great story. I was completely captivated. Amazing. I like your portrayal of the characters, Tom's especially. And the storyline.
The only thing, I did not quite get, was the epilogue, how Tom is defeated. And how did Albus die? Maybe I was too into reading that I didn't grasp everyting. (:
Keep up writing. |
 REMUS IS DODGY 2004-07-28 . chapter 9Bloody brilliant! Absolutely bloody brilliant! I am...I'm speechless! I must say this is one of the best fan fictions I have EVER read! Keep up the fantastic writing! |
 Holly version 2.0 2004-07-27 . chapter 9First, I would like to thank you for writting the best fanfic I have ever read. I envy you with this fanfic. You have much talent in writting and I am honored to be able to read this fic.
You are the ultimate Minerva/Riddle shipper, thank you SO much for writting this and posting it. It was fantastic, beautifully written, and very logical.
If I knew where you lived, I'd send you a fruit basket. Yep. Once again, thank you, thank you, thank you for writting this!
-Holly ^^
PS.
I am serious about this being the best fanfic I have ever read! |
 Rio 2004-05-23 . chapter 9 What an unusual pairing, yet you made it seem so believable. I'm surprised this story hasn't gotten more reviews, it's wonderful. You have a beautiful writing style, it's descriptive, yet not overly so, what makes it easy to read and the plot flow smoothly.
You also are the first fanfiction Author that has managed to make me cry. Seriously, chapter 8 was unbelievably sad, and the way you portrayed the emotions involved was really intense - absolutely amazing. As soon as I find my ff.net password this will go on my favorites list (stupid lil me can't remember it as usual after not logging in for a while... it has to be a curse of sorts) |
 SilverDragonsFlame 2004-04-16 . chapter 9wow, this story was amazing...very well written. i could understand the love between them, and at the same time, the destiny that neither could fight. *sigh* i usually like fluffy endings, but this story more than made up for a non happily-ever-after fluff ending :)
~carlee |
 Marie Falcon 2004-04-01 . chapter 1 brilliant. beautiful. poignant. memorable. this is one of my all time favourite HP fanfiction. |
 Cadabra 2004-03-12 . chapter 9Absoloutely brilliantly written. Powerful, and beautiful. Going on favorites, thank you for this! You have converted me to the MM/TR ship. |