Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: LotR Haiku - Page 1 of 2
Nurvingiel
2004-09-25 . chapter 1
These haiku's are great! I especially liked Boromir's and Aragorn's. Gandalf's was really funny! (Wears a pointy hat is a humorous line, even though it's true.)

Regardless of what side you're on in the Hair Debate, Legolas would be blond, not blonde, because he's a dude.

I first discovered your work by reading the hilarious MST of "Taken Far Too Literally". I'm glad this happened because you write very well. I think you'll be a successful actual author. You can realize your dream! (I am also an aspiring actual author.)

Cheerio! Nurv
twin03
2004-01-09 . chapter 2
Nice! I don't usually read poetry, but I'm glad I gave this a try.
Oort
2003-09-22 . chapter 2
These are pretty good, especially the villians. I love Saurons.
Flame Tigress
2003-08-21 . chapter 1
Just my two cents' worth: Legolas is blond. He's a Telerin Elf, and they've all got pale, kind of silver-blond hair -- not to be confused with the golden hair of the Vanyar. If someone can quote a passage of LotR that says he's brunette, I'll believe it, but not until.

Otherwise -- nice haikus!
Chanra
2003-05-25 . chapter 2
Brilliant. I've never liked poetry, but your fanfic makes me change my mind!
TigerLily713
2003-05-20 . chapter 1
Oh...I like it. Nice job. Lily
Heiress_of_Hufflepuff
2003-05-10 . chapter 2
Really good! Would you right more sometime?
Songbreeze Swifteye
2003-05-09 . chapter 2
wonderful haiku, once again! very vividly described, you really have a way with words! nicely written, great job. keep up your writing! could you read my LotR haiku?
Songbreeze Swifteye
2003-05-09 . chapter 1
awesome haiku! very well written with all the essence of haiku. you described these characters very well. good job on these! keep on writing!
fodmonkey
2003-05-06 . chapter 1
yeah i always thought he'd b brown haired!

2 right bout Pippin!
PuterPatty
2003-05-05 . chapter 2
OOh! I like, I like very much! Haikus are great fun and you've really managed to capture those key characterizations using only 17 syllables. Bravo!

Now how about some for the Races of Middle-earth, or other characters--Elrond, Glorfindel, Galadriel, Faramir, Eomer, Eowyn, Haldir, Treebeard, Celeborn, Tom Bombadil, Halbarad, Imrahil, Elladan, Elrohir, Ghan-buri-Ghan...So many to choose from! ::puppy dog eyes:: Please?
Sleepy Jean
2003-05-05 . chapter 2
I'm not even going to try to be eloquent, so I'll just say this: I loved 'em all! :D
Nodalec
2003-04-29 . chapter 1
Yay! Fun haikus! Kudos to poetry! These were really good. ^.^ I don't think I could write a haiku if my life depended on it. I especially liked Gandalf's haiku. Go pointy hats!
Drew Marigold
2003-04-29 . chapter 1
*stands and applauds* Very nicely done! I always stand in awe of people who can produce decent poetry. I can't. You can. Wonderfully, in fact!

I just have one _minor, teeny, tiny_ nitpick (call it CC if we want to sound nicer):
"I thought he'd be blonde"... should be "blond."
This stems back from French: girls are blonde, guys are blond - no 'e'. (Sorry, that's just the language teacher coming out in me. It won't happen again. *thunks Language Teacher Drew over the head with something very heavy* *Language Teacher Drew crumples to the floor*)

*goes back to being awed* Keep it up! I look forward to reading your 'obscure characters' series.
sunsong
2003-04-29 . chapter 1
I wish I could write like this! I'm much better with flames than praise, but trust me, these are awesome.
Return to Top