Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Cold As Any Stone - Page 1 of 2
Aranel Abeille 9/12/05 . chapter 1
Amazing. I am completely awestruck. You handle the time changes so smoothly- and in fact the jumping around is part of what makes this story so awesome. Your writing is... wow. I'm speechless. This is now my favorite Alias fic. Ever.
Alexis6 7/6/03 . chapter 1
This has got to be one of my favorite Alias stories-put it somewhere in the top three.

What I love about your fics (I sent you feedback for "Say What" a while ago) is that they are so well-written. I don't know how you approach the art and craft of writing (in terms of the number of drafts and idea formulation), but I do know (from what I can tell) that you don't half-ass anything: everything is well-crafted and polished and sounds just right. "Cold as Any Stone" is an all-around great story-from concept to execution.

What I love about this story in particular was the creative approach, the way the story was told out of order but made sense as the transitions were thematically connected.

I was also impressed by the way you maintained the tension throughout, even though the story starts out at the end. That's something: you didn't rely on the audience asking "what's going to happen in the end?" in order to build the suspense.

And like I said earlier, "Stone" is well-written and well-crafted, but because of the fractured narrative, it remains a little rough: it somehow strikes a fine balance between polished and raw.

So great job. Consider me a fan, because I've been reading some of your other fics and I don't even watch Buffy. I look forward to your reading more of your stories (for Alias hopefully)...
OliviaB 5/15/03 . chapter 1
i can't remember who put up a rec for this story, maybe TWoP, but anyway, i am really glad i listened, it was really very well written, i'm going to read more of your stuff right now.
Duck 5/1/03 . chapter 1
I've read a lot of fics by a lot of different authors... Yours have always stood out to me, because you're so incredibly talented. "Say What?" will always be my favorite fic of all time, and I believe this one has kicked its way to the top as well. This left me speechless, and I've already read it more than once. I hope you feel inspired to write more Alias fics, because you are so amazing.

*Duck
Princess Hunny Bee 5/1/03 . chapter 1
wow. very good. the jumping back and forth from present to past was a little confusing, but i caught on after a while.

i was really afraid he was going to die! im glad you arent one of those vaughn-killing authors. :)
Taffi-01 5/1/03 . chapter 1
Loved that - like the complex way it was written - that's the way I'd love to write, but I think too linearly... ...cool but v weird ending though... are you going to do a follow up?
nattie700 5/1/03 . chapter 1
Yay! Finally another Alias story. I've been killing myself waitng for another one from you guys! Say What was the best and normally I don't really like action kind of ones but I love yours!

Ages ago I wrote to you asking for advice and you wrote back with a whole page. Thankyou so much! I can't tell you how much that meant to me. I took all your advice and I'm writing two Alias stories at the momment.

Thankyou, thankyou, thankyou so much.

Please write more Alias fics!
valley-girl2 4/30/03 . chapter 1
omg, that was ABSOLUTELY fantastic, just great. throughout the whole story you cautiously let us know what was going on, it was just great. write more! expand this! whatever, something!
Alliecat3 4/30/03 . chapter 1
OMG. What a fantastic story! It was brilliantly planned and executed and really had the feel of an episode. I didn't find it difficult to follow and I love the ambiguity of the ending. The characters were pitch perfect, and I'm glad you had Vaughn ask the question about hiding the ampoule, because I wondered that myself! The only tiny quibble I have is your use of the word "petrol" instead of "gas", which you may want to edit.

Very well done and I look forward to more of your work!
iluvpie 4/30/03 . chapter 1
ok.. im confused... the plot was to jolty...
iluvpie 4/30/03 . chapter 1
ok.. im confused... the plot was to jolty...
snowangel 4/30/03 . chapter 1
Wow. This story was amazing. It was a little difficult to follow at first but got alot better. Very suspenseful! I think you wrote Sydney's character very well, great job! Im looking forward to more! (0:
Duck 4/30/03 . chapter 1
Wow. I'm totally totally blown away by this awesome piece of fic. You wrote my all time favorite story, "Say What?", and this comes to a close second. This had me twisted around, the way I like it, and just... I'm at a loss for words.
Raina 4/30/03 . chapter 1
Huh? What is that ening suposed to mean? It left me with an impending sense of doom.Really cool story though. Where did you get that idea. i could have never thought of that.
Nadja 4/30/03 . chapter 1
Wow. That was... wonderful. I don't quite know what to say. It was just... wow. Great job!
17 found: Page 1 2 Next »
Return to Top