Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: An Elegy for Elfhild
RavenLady
2006-04-23 . chapter 1
Oh - oh - oh. I love this to pieces. It is absolutely beautiful, and the characters shine right through.
Orangeblossom Took1
2003-06-22 . chapter 1
Poor Theoden *sobs* This is a wonderful poem.
Marnie
2003-06-21 . chapter 1
Fabulous! Stern, dignified, very Old English and very touching. Absolutely right.
ErinRua
2003-06-20 . chapter 1
Beautiful ...

This had so many haunting and touching images in it, and just the right ring of "age" and time to make it seem an ancient work. I am not scholar of poetry, I can't tell a sonnet from a bonnet, but the meter and pacing of this really strike me as perfect for stately verse written by a kingly man in deep mourning. One might almost think it a translation of some aged text somewhere. Very nice, and very sad. Thank you for sharing this!
Cheers ~

Erin
Elvasdottir
2003-06-20 . chapter 1
This is very good. I am not sure what the punctuation rules are for this sort of poetry, but if it will not violate them you may wish to consider using periods or semi-colons to mark where a sentence or independent clause ends. It caused me a bit of confusion here and there while reading. Otherwise, this is fine writing. Thank you for sharing it.
Return to Top