Really good. I would like to read what Severus says to Harry someday.

Really good.

It isn't that bad. The idea is good.

great story so far

This was a good beginning to your fic. After five years, though, I think this fic is pretty well abandoned. Kind of a shame, really. This plot was interesting and had great potential.

Please continue with this story, because it is really good!

ew yeah me want more!

A bit angsty yes? Looking forward to more. Thanks

I really enjoyed reading these 3 chapters and wished you would have continued the story.

please update. its really good. i'm dying to read more.

This is good, why has it been left?
I always thought with book 6 Harry hadnt really spent much grief over the matter and it was very much left alone.
I liked Snape's role in the last chapter, and Lupin's overall...there should be more of that guy...plus the possesion and sleepwalking were favourite bits...its a concept (being possessed) that i'm suprised hasnt been used more often, or indeed in the books...to be caught unawares makes for an interesting story piece.
Now if only you would not end it there...and why is it 'tragedy' will Harry die or sumthing or are u just refering to sirius?

awesome

Who knows when indeed!! This is a brilliant story, and I would love to find out what happens in later chapters, have you continued somewhere else perhaps? But after 18 months, I have this dread that this fic is dead in the water. If it is, oh well. I've thoroughly enjoyed the read so far, you were definately going somewhere, and have this great talent for writing. I remember the days of Bad Dreams, one the first fics I read. I hope you do continue though.

Cheers
Kimberley

I love it. I love that you've got snape and remus there so much, being active charaters. it's perfect. cannot wait to see more, so update soon!

Well, you wrote 3 wonderfull chapters - care for going on for us? Doesn´t matter it doesn´t suit to HBP!