Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Requiem I : Wishing for Gravestones
Melenna
2005-03-04 . chapter 1
Wow. Just wow. I loved it. For sure one of the best i've read yet. Good job.
:Goes away to cry:
Padfoot n' Moony
2004-10-09 . chapter 1
so sad...
Letters to Charlie
2004-08-10 . chapter 1
Oh my god I loved it! Something I'd write...very sentimental. Absolutely amazing.
padfootfe
2004-02-12 . chapter 1
The story may be over, but my tears are still falling. That touched my heart like nothing else except when Sirius died in book 5.
Amaya Dima
2003-08-02 . chapter 1
OMG!! I just finished reading OOtP again and still cry when Sirius died...and this brought me to tears just after I managed to stop crying...anyway...this is a great story...really sad and and I loved it...putting you on my Favorite Authors list and this story on my Favorite Stories list...*goes to read OOtP...again*
Paz
2003-08-02 . chapter 1
This was one of the most beautiful, and sorrowful, stories I have read about Sirius and Harry. The gentle love and the nostalgic sadness in it had my eyes shining with tears, something which rarely happens to me. I cherished the sweet moments they had, and mourned along with Harry for Sirius. The realism in your writting is fantastic. The story's beautiful because it's just so real, the characters are portrayed very well, and the words you chose convey so much so simply. A lovely piece of writting overall.
Aeglowyn
2003-07-02 . chapter 1
*sobs* I miss Siri...thanks for giving us all this in our time of grief...*runs away to sob more*
Theoriginalflame
2003-06-25 . chapter 1
Damn! God damn that was sad, I hate JK How could she?! How could she!! She killed siri! I loved siri he was my fave! But she killed him.

Any way, on to your story. OH MY GOD! That was the sweetst most depressing thing I have ever read at one time. You are one hell of a writer, a total natural at it!


I was almost in tears, its so beautifully haunting. a million and a half out of ten!

~flame
Perdolwen
2003-06-24 . chapter 1
::sob::

That was beautiful. It made me start crying again. The emotion put into this piece is just wonderful.

Definatly adding this to my favorites.
Ms. Padfoot
2003-06-24 . chapter 1
Oh. My. God. That was absolutely beautiful! I am astonished that you were able to form a coherent thought about Sirius so quickly. I am still in shock. I will be printing up a copy of this for my own private collection of things about my Paddy. I hope you don't mind

Ms. Padfoot
Return to Top