Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Ion Nin
sielge
2005-06-28 . chapter 1
This was a beautiful piece of work...
Catmint
2004-02-13 . chapter 1
So beautiful.
Arien Laurelin
2003-10-22 . chapter 1
The inclusion of Elvish was a very nice finishing touch. There are few stories around centralizing Gilraen, so it is always refreshing to read a piece involving her.
Doranwen
2003-09-09 . chapter 1
*gasps* What is this I see? Non-'Net Elvish? *smiles in great appreciation* It may not be perfect (as Nenwe already pointed out a grammatical error), but I must congratulate you upon using true Sindarin. It gives me much joy to know there are still fanfic writers who know something about Tolkien's beloved languages, which started this whole world.
Kaz
2003-07-02 . chapter 1
What a great idea for a little fic, I loved it :o)
I especially loved the Arwen reference.
Love Kaz
xx
Silraen
2003-06-30 . chapter 1
Oh...my...God! Cait! It's so beautifully written! {Not counting the grammatical and spelling errors *wink*} But really, it is EXTREMELY well done for only your second Gilraen fic! This letter fits her character and personality perfectly, and I love how you added in Arwen with the whole "She watches you. She loves you. With love, you are never alone." thing. PERFECT! Kudos to you, hun! :D

~Silraen {aka Arwen, Dee, Fiesty or whathaveyou...}
Nenwe
2003-06-28 . chapter 1
Beautiful. Short and sweet, well done. :) There aren't many Gilraen stories around and I'm glad you've posted this one.

But you might want to change "naneth nin" to "naneth chin". Nin is for the first person possessive, while chin is for the second person possessive. Just a bit of a grammar note there... ;)
Frodo3791
2003-06-28 . chapter 1
Tis very sad. We don't hear much about Aragorn's mother. Very good.
-Frodo
Daisy Brambleburr
2003-06-28 . chapter 1
That was very nice. A good, original idea and well written to boot. Nice work!
ArwenUndomiel
2003-06-27 . chapter 1
Wow. Very well written. Great work, and it was a great idea.
Ilya Turelie
2003-06-27 . chapter 1
~ OMG that is so sad, and so sweet! I love it, you are a very talented writer. Keep it up!! :)
ps. Did i mention that i loved it? ~
Return to Top