I like everything you write, and this is no exception! Bittersweet!

I especially loved the last line! Of course she would!

;)

One word. Brilliant.

Brilliant, and powerful. Great job!

Good mercy this was so sad. Oh my goodness. And it's exactly how I felt when I read about Sirius' death. I kept thinking, 'he's going to come out now. He's going to come out and he'll be fine and Harry's going to hug him and they'll all live happily ever after.' But that didn't happen. Denial and love are such beautiful, cruel things, aren't they?

Truly thorned roses.

I'm kind of confused . . .

All my love,

Lily

Sob...breaks my heart...

How sad! I liked it. Always Hopeful

Beautiful! I loved it. Sad, but realistic with just the right amount of poignancy.

Reviewing this for the third time. Just to say that I'm crying again. And that I really, really love this.
3 times. Um, wow. Clearly I've finally gone off of my nuter :-P
But, wow. This story. Is just. Like, wow. I love it so much. If I could fill up my Favorite Stories list with it, I would, just to pay it homage.
So, off to go read anything starring any character Jason Isaacs ever played. Love you.
Lurve,
*CEA

Kay, I just had to review this again cause I just read my first review and wanted to slap myself.
Did I ever tell you that every time I read this, I cry? I'm serious. It's pure sorrow, and so awfully soul-searing. The idea that never will he be able to tell her that he loves her tears at me so deeply... it... well, it makes me cry. Gods, I could go on forever about how terribly sad that makes me feel...
Suffice to say, I love this fic, and I still want to slap you for calling yourself mediocre.
Love,
*CEA
(who very much wants you to update After The Battle)

Oh god! That was by FAR the saddest thing I've ever read! How could you do that? I mean, here I am reading this, thinking "well, someone's dead", and I can't wait for her to come over and then that! That was totally unexpected and so sad! This really touched me, and usually no sad stories do, but this is really good, I am lacking words to describe this little piece's affect on me *sniffs*

Inca

*sob* So sweet yet so very very sad. You wrote this magically, and your poem is a piece of priceless art. Soo...beautiful. Poor Dumbledore. *sob* Wonderful. Write more.

i can't see why you feel you're a bad writer or anything like that... what did you say? mediore? rubbish! you made me want to cry, and, believe me, thats something!

loved it - keep it up!

*GG*

aw... That's sad. poor Albus.

Well, I have to say that the melodramatic angst turned out rather well. In fact, I thought it was rather brilliant, though short. The idea that now she'll 'never know' his true feelings, or never be able to share that something new is particularly heart wrenching. Albus' grief, hidden in denial was intensely soul disturbing and , well, it was very sad. Very, very sad, I'll go find a tissue now, a good fic.