Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: By This, And This Only - Page 1 of 3
EdgeofDarkness
2009-08-16 . chapter 1
makes me sad because Snape ha sno idea how right his feeling is...but its kinglsey that loses him. SAd, but lovley and nice all the same.
Ali-chan et Vani-chan
2009-03-30 . chapter 1
My first Kingsley+Sev fic! And it was so beautiful too:O I loved it so much. You write so well! Do you think you will write more fic with that pairing? And could you send me the second part of your Sev+Draco fic. I couldn't find it anywhere. thanks for the fic;p
Amarinta
2009-01-06 . chapter 1
Wonderful. Perfect. So f**king amazing. Severus's monologue just brought me to tears.
Bye
black laurel
2008-12-13 . chapter 1
I know that you no longer post at , but I still felt compelled to review.

This fic is very unique, and beautiful, in it's own way. That's all I wanted to say.
thafemaleshacklebolt
2007-03-11 . chapter 1
I dont think anyone else could have written it better. fantabulous
kayly silverstorm
2006-02-28 . chapter 1
Beautiful!
random reader
2005-01-01 . chapter 1
What a brilliant pairing. I read this story quite a while back and I find myself coming back to reread every now and then. Its as good as the first time everytime.It's become one of my favorite fics. Now I look for kingsley/snape fics everywhere I read but have only managed to find one. Thankfully it is quite good and their should be a sequel. For anyone whose interested it is written by kai and you can find her stories at I would really like to see this story continued as well. What if I said pretty please with sugar on top...
spirals
2004-10-07 . chapter 1
AWW! Sweet!! I like it! Is there gonna be anymore/sequel/etc of it? That would be nice...
skinnyrita
2004-07-22 . chapter 1
loved this fic immensely. odd, never seen this pairing before.
shrewface
2004-06-18 . chapter 1
Oh, this is absolutely wonderful! You’ve managed to capture the essence of these (vastly unappreciated, in my opinion) characters. The relationship is written so naturally and so well, I could easily believe it were true – it’s like reading canon-slash, like reading about a real relationship woven into the Harry Potter Canon world. I shall simply weep if you don’t visit this genius pairing again in future fics – even if it’s just a fleeting scribble on a napkin … *clears throat*. Sorry, I got a little carried away. Point was: Wonderful.

Sepentium
Jedusor
2003-10-06 . chapter 1
E! Excellent! I hate it when people do Snape/Harry or Snape/Anybody and set it in the future and have Snape all repentant and back-to-the-good-side and all, it's really annoying. But this captures the essence of Snape well (of course, I already knew you could write Snape). A little more angsty than he generally is, but I was warned, so I can't complain. Good job!
Feather
2003-08-27 . chapter 1
This was positively brilliant! Though I normally don't like to ramble, I found this piece exquisite in style, execution, and concept. The pairing, of course, is quite unique, but somehow, you made it work brilliantly, Dien Alcyone. And though it ended on a higher note, the questionings of war and why to love in spite of all terrible things happening were, for me, the most touching thing in this fic. Once again, I commend you: excellent, excellent job!
N. Marie
2003-08-13 . chapter 1
Beautiful, simply beautiful. I've no other word. This was amazing, kudos to you.
Marylou
2003-08-09 . chapter 1
I'm so, so jealous!

I have just started writing a Kingsley/Snape fic and I was hoping to be the first...Ahh!

Anyway, I loved your story, very emotional and the characterisation of Kingsley was lovely.
Coesius
2003-08-06 . chapter 1
okay, i started from this story (read: ADSS review); the pairing seemed interesting. It is great, Kingsley seemed an interesting character for me while reading the book and i liked how you explored him. The story of course is perfect. I love the snape angst. You write snape very beautifully. keep writing!
love,
coesius
Return to Top