 dancingkatz 2007-11-29 . chapter 1You made me cry with this fic. Tears of sorrow and in the end tears of hope. Beautifully written.
You even managed to make me feel sorry for hte portrait of Mrs. Black, something I didn't think anyone or anything could do.
Dancingkatz |
 OTP 2007-07-25 . chapter 1wonderfully done |
 Taigan 2005-03-24 . chapter 1This was so bittersweet. I particularly liked that Sirius' mother seemed broken up about her son's death. It seems fitting afterall that she would still mourn him even though she sees him as a traitor.
I thought that this was very good. I liked the dynamic between Tonks and Lupin. I thought their reactions in light of what had just happened were very appropriate.
I'm rather surprised that you haven't written anymore fanfiction in the Harry Potter Universe. I hope that you write more. I like your style. |
 Rita 2004-08-19 . chapter 1 T/L... yes, this is why I read this fic. You know I think Rowling is really planning somthing like that. Remus either dies or gets a better life... I would like to see the latter but it's up to Rowling as everything else...Moony would really deservi it for one, but Sirius WOULD HAVE deserved it too... It is all gessing until the next book comes out ... about a year or so until than |
 Rhiannon Deschain 2004-03-07 . chapter 1*Sniffle* Oi...that was lovely. *dabs eyes* Wonderfully written... *gives a well deserved cupcake* They were completely in character too.. *bounce* Me likie. Well done!! |
 Stellar Snape 2003-12-03 . chapter 1That was beautifully written Tracey! You even made me feel a bit sorry for Sirius' mother. But sometimes it is the situations like this that shake us to the core. I imagine even an animate painting feels something as profound as death. Excellent! |
 dazed*kitten 2003-09-29 . chapter 1Very nice, and well written. A good addition to the Harry Potter fanfiction archive (as opposed to some other, less well-written, less thought-out, less original, less... less stories).
*kitten |
 DumbledoresQuill 2003-09-04 . chapter 1Thank you for reviewing my piece. Sorry about the spelling but there is no spell checker on notepad and I haven't re-installed microsoft word. I'm usually good except when i'm tired.lol
Anyway,You're piece is very good and I hope you continue with it because I would like to see what happens. Obviously you feel in your heart what i do when i'm writing.
Naomi x
(dumbledoresquill) |
 DistinctVagueness 2003-08-29 . chapter 1This really did achieve it's purpose. So sad and very touching. Love your take on NT/RL. |
 Strega Brava 2003-08-21 . chapter 1 This was a truly poignant vignette and it made me feel a myriad of different emotions. Simply lovely. |
 Anacalagon 2003-08-08 . chapter 1Very sweet story. |
 Deimos (not logged in) 2003-07-16 . chapter 1 This is one of the first OOtP pairings I've come upon...I think it's perfect. Tonks and Lupin would make a good couple, and I love the way you wrote the chapter and the "mild adult situation". It was very sweet. Write more! |
 TheEvilDooer 2003-07-14 . chapter 1Aw, sad... T.T |
 kate 2003-07-13 . chapter 1 Good stuff |
 nycgrl 2003-07-13 . chapter 1Very sweet :) I love the RL/NT ship. Good job. I also liked how you wrote Sirius' mother's reaction. Hope to read more R/T from you! |