 Nymma 2009-10-31 . chapter 24Very well written:) Please update soon! |
 Tchitchina 2009-09-25 . chapter 24I love your fic! The short notes are such a great idea, sometimes it can be a bit frustrating because we don't know exactly what happened with every details, but I enjoy it a lot. Your writing is very good and I Love the way you unfold the story. I hope that one day you'll finish it! |
 Leitheindel 2009-08-23 . chapter 2Really good fic as far as I've read, but two things in this chapter annoyed me a bit... Firstly, Frank Longbottom's mother's name is Augusta Longbottom, and secondly the whole "Minerva loves Severus"-bit, since she was old enough to teach at Hogwarts when he went to school... :P |
 Anachronistic Anglophile 2009-07-12 . chapter 4I cannot believe that Dumbledore would be so unmoving! Unless he's jealous of one or the other of them? He's always been of the opinion 'love, and be loved'...does he want Severus or Minerva? He would not be the authoritarian figure in this. He'd turn a blind eye to it, if not completely condone it. |
 slavetothekeyboard 2008-10-27 . chapter 1I don't like the note writing style myself but this I like. |
 hobgoblinn 2008-07-12 . chapter 24Looks like this has been dormant for some time, which is a shame. I have really enjoyed the dynamic here, and you've achieved a remarkable amount of character and plot development through such a distancing medium (epistolary novels have never been my favorite.) Really nice work. I would not be sad to see an update sometime. Though perhaps knowing how canon turned out you would have trouble getting this tale to slot in so well s you have the first part.
Thanks for sharing this. |
 hobgoblinn 2008-07-12 . chapter 8I stumbled across this on someone else's favorites and I just want to say how wonderfully written this is. I didn't expect you to be able to sustain it long, and Minerva and Severus are kind of a difficult couple to wrap one's mind around. But you've captured a snarky close friendship beautifully. I'm really impressed and just wanted to tell you so before I read anymore. Well done, truly. |
 JoSchmo666 2007-08-15 . chapter 24Roflmao! This is absolutely hilarious. I love it! |
 EmptyWord 2007-05-15 . chapter 1This is cute. Snape would call it an abomination of course, but he doesn't get much of a say in the humor genre. I look forward to the next chapters. |
 LadyCarter 2007-05-05 . chapter 24Excellent |
 Skyline Romance 2007-05-03 . chapter 24U are great! All hail the fabulous Minerva and her Tartan Bra! :) |
 Charlotte 2007-05-01 . chapter 24 great chapter! loved the last line |
 Ember Koramin 2007-04-29 . chapter 7I really like this, it's certainly a side we've I've never seen in then before. And It definatley has very humorous bits in it.^_^ |
 Naked Winged Naraku 2007-04-14 . chapter 1lol, funny. |
 DailyProphetEditor 2007-03-19 . chapter 24Oh, how funny!
You let Minerva and Severus go a bit OOC, I think, but it did not really matter. I love the notes style, and some scenes were so funny I laughed out loud. Really a good one! |