Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Character Sketches - Page 1 of 3
N16
2007-08-02 . chapter 9
I rarely find fanfic I like - very rarely - and I am loving this so far. It's absolutely fantastic. You have Remus and Sirius, my favorites, and I love how they're handled. I love that there's tension there, and how you handle Sirius's darkness. You don't ignore it, but you don't use it to alienate the reader. I also like how you handle Remus in the same way, showing his flaws and showing his selfish side, but doing it in a way that is still very endearing, and very real.

The reason that I am leaving a review now and not earlier is that I simply had to stop and comment on "He Who Must Not Be Named Because He Makes Mum and Dad Cry." That line was absolutely incredible. It really shows how a child's mind works, and it was heartbreaking.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 10
that was really sad. yeah, remus is used to pain: the death of his best friend, the betrayal of another... but it still hurts.

you described it wonderfully. his pain, i mean. i loved:

"It follows him around like a little lost puppy that always finds its home in him."

that really touched me. in fact this whole fic touched me. update soon!
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 9
thats really sweet. brotherly love (*sadly* o course I'M an only child) its sad too. percy used to love his family so much. and look what happened now!
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 8
you described remus's thoughts perfectly. he's right. he cant replace sirius and he doesnt want to either.

i liked it.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 7
what goes on in sirius's mind? no one knows. no one knew. but you've told us. sirius only acts like a crazy hyper arrogant prankster to hide from what's REALLY on his mind. to hide from his emotions.

you described it beautifully.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 6
that was beautiful. you described it beautifully. sirius's emotions: guilt, sorrow, loneliness. and the feeling of being trapped.

poor sirius.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 5
yay! sirius again! : >

that was def your best. very sweet and sad. poor sirius.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 4
this is from percy's point of veiw? *scowls* the git. OF COURSE his parents would be disappointed in him. he betrayed them!

of course, it IS a pain in the ** when they say that.

MOM: how could you do that? YOU'RE GROUNDED!

ME: but mom -

MOM: no buts! TO YOUR ROOM!

ME: FINE!! bloody FINE!

MOM: (as i storm up the stairs) i'm so dsappointed in you

ME:(mumbling) what? its not like i did a percy.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 3
poor sirius. his parents were evil. in a way, remus WAS luckier. at least HIS parents loved him.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 2
i'd hate to be a metamorphmagus. if you change your face so many times, you dont really know who you are.

i liked this one. tonks is just trying to hide from the person she really is. nice.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 2
i'd hate to be a metamorphmagus. if you change your face so many times, you dont really know who you are.

i liked this one. tonks is just trying to hide from the person she really is. nice.
PadfootGal
2005-07-15 . chapter 1
aww thats really sad. that must have been how sirius felt after he had reunited with his best friend after 12 long years. all those years remus had thought him to be a traitor. and now? he's just confused.

nice one. i liked it. you described it well.
C.Y.Myers
2005-06-22 . chapter 10
that's so sad.
i'm sorry if my reviews started getting weird and short, but i'm running out of stuff to say!!~
C.Y.Myers
2005-06-22 . chapter 9
aww... that's so sweet.~
C.Y.Myers
2005-06-22 . chapter 8
that was really good. it sounded just like harry, actually. that's hard to do sometimes, capturing the character. i really like these drabbles, and you write them wonderfully.~
Return to Top