Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The Stars Have a Secret - Page 1 of 6
Emma58
2004-08-03 . chapter 2
Again I find that you have used grammar incorrectly, in the form of not using a , within in the speech.

This seems a good plot, but it would be better if you explained more about what Ginny's on about- not everybody has knowlege about the stars.

-Emma
Emma58
2004-08-03 . chapter 1
Firstly, this is constructive critisism. Not a flame. Please, please do not consider this to be a flame.

I have found some things wrong with the first chapter. For one, Ginny and Harry act wildly OOC (out of character).

For two, the effects of the Obliviate spell are not that someone forgets and then goes all Luna, and then decides to blurt out their feelings and kiss the nearest person. They merely make somebody forget.

From what we can gather, the only reason that Lockhart went all dreamy aafter the spell is that it had gone wrong, due to Ron's broken wand.

You don't use speech properly in the story. You type, for example "Yup" without the comma that should follow it. The correct way of writing it would be "Yup,".

I hope this helps you, and I will carry on reading and review again soon.

-Emma
TrinMalfoy
2003-05-19 . chapter 4
I think it was quite cute- how did you figure those things out about the stars? Did you make it up?

2001-07-10 . chapter 4
Megan
2001-06-12 . chapter 4
good but i think that you should do more. i am really anticipating what is going to happen!!! i want to read more, hear the rest!!! hurry up!!! :P please??!!!!!
Written above to happen below ( I know bad pun)
2001-06-03 . chapter 4
awwww.... that was so sweet.
the-green-bard
2001-05-31 . chapter 4
this story is so true. and gin's my fav. u?
Chicken Peep
2001-05-08 . chapter 4
hmmmmmm.........
ZONKOFRED
2001-05-07 . chapter 1
Short, but it sounds like it'll be another good one! =)
magicalangel
2001-04-28 . chapter 4
That didn't suck. It was the SWEETEST story! I'm sorry to say, but the sappy, fluffy stories with happy endings are my favorite. I thought that was great. :):):) I love, LOVE h/g fics and r/hr fics. harry/cho fics are good too. Any sappy romances suit me. ::smiles:: I love it how you made Ginny so confident and mysterious!! Perfect.
Serena-chan1
2001-04-09 . chapter 4
I loved it!!!!
Princess Luna
2001-04-07 . chapter 4
That was very cute! Odd twist too..
Slyv
2001-03-21 . chapter 4
The whole 4 parter is so cute love it!
Amethyst
2001-01-29 . chapter 4
Why would I say it sucked? Great job!
ginny potter10
2001-01-29 . chapter 1
That was really good!!!!!!! g/h is the only way to go!!!!!!(and of course r/h)
Return to Top