Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Becoming Numb - Page 1 of 2
jimmy-barnes-13
2007-04-23 . chapter 1
*sob* that was so sad! Beautifully written :)
Midnightdreamr
2005-11-26 . chapter 1
SADNESS! Poor Leggy! He wanted to see Haldir in the Havens. HALDIR SHOULD HAVE BEEN THERE! GREAT STORY THOUGH!

~KG~
CosmicalMadison
2004-02-13 . chapter 1
Very nicely written. You did very well at describing emotions.
*sniff, tear* R.I.P. Haldir
Reasonably crazy
2003-11-02 . chapter 1
Aw... *sniffle* *tear*

'Course, Haldir doesn't die in the books, but still... *cry* *sniffle*

Haldir!
mikazuki
2003-10-18 . chapter 1
*sob*
write more
Silvawen the Elf Crumpet
2003-10-18 . chapter 1
Aw, that's really sad, really sweet and really well written!
Oh, I feel like crying now.
Luvs Elfie x
Roselyne
2003-10-08 . chapter 1
*opens wide eyes with awe...* *O*

WOW! :,)...

How sad but how beautiful :,)...

Now, the danger for Legolas is to die of grief (usually lethal for elves...). Did you see it this way? :,|...
Hidden
2003-09-05 . chapter 1
that was so sad!
Good but sad!
Star-Stallion
2003-08-28 . chapter 1
='( Haldir wasnt supposed to die. The Elves werent even meant to be there, apart from Legolas. I thought PJ was *so* evil 4 killing so many! This was an excellent fanfic, well done! =)

+RIP Haldir+ ='(

~*~ Star-Stallion ~*~
Marchwriter
2003-08-23 . chapter 1
* sniff * So sad. I liked it.
ivorybrowneyes
2003-08-21 . chapter 1
argh! Ya know, personally, I didn't mind Peter Jackson bringing in the Elves. I honestly think it was a good thing, despite that Legolas is supposed to feel betrayed. But I think slaying Haldir was taking too much of a liberty...I only curse Peter Jackson for major changes, and this was going too far. But what a tribute to our fallen hero...but then again, we all know what REALLY happened, correct? And trust me, anyone who has seen it, I blurt out that Haldir was NOT supposed to die. *smiles for all Haldir fans* I love this tribute. Go you!
CLW
2003-08-05 . chapter 1
hey...this is cindy...that is really good!! i like it despit its legolas...lol jk. but its very well written!! very depressing. k ttyl. good job! can't wait to read the fellowship! hehe.

~CLW~
resqmi
2003-08-04 . chapter 1
very nice. not usually a legolas fan, but i am a haldir fan and this is well written and heartfelt. glad i found it. HALDIR LIVES
Guo-Xing Choi
2003-08-03 . chapter 1
Oh, I hope that's not the end.
White Wolf1
2003-08-03 . chapter 1
Very sad. You did a good job describing Legolas' emotions. I'd hate to think that he remained numb for too long. He has a lot of living yet to do.
Return to Top