Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Silver and Gold
Animus Wyrmis
2005-07-28 . chapter 1
Excellent! I love Neville fics. This one's amazing -- the strong Slytherin, the gold vs silver, the characterization. Awesome job. Well-written, and a huge plot twist at the end.
Monica
2004-07-20 . chapter 1
This was very cleverly written. When I think back on it, Neville is the only person who could logically kill off Voldemort if Harry failed. I wouldn't have thought of Neville as a Slytherin, but nevertheless it was an interesting read.
SweetSorrow1
2003-12-31 . chapter 1
Neville? A Slytherin? ... I always knew he had it in him!! Get Neville!
~Sweet Sorrow
PS: Great work on this. You kept me guessing and I was surprised in the end. Great work.
Observer of Harry and Draco's Sweet Lurve
2003-12-25 . chapter 1
Neville Longbottom?!...
NEVILLE...
he's a slytherin?
>.
care
2003-08-15 . chapter 1
this is... incredible. now, there are some parts that were slightly confusing - ie the "taking center stage whenever humiliation needs to be doled out, whenever contempt and censure needs to flow like wine," but i can see that you've just added that to ensure the idea of draco. and because yes, Neville does seem to humiliate himself seemingly strategically. a very interesting take on Neville you have there. it's a wonderful twist, it really is. esp since everyone dismisses Neville so easily. after OOtP came out, i've expected waves of Neville-centric fics, but was incredibly surprised to see that so few people picked up the ficcing plot that rowling practically handed to us on a silver platter. and the few that i have seen were all written sub-standard, but this one is fascinating. it explains Neville's reason for being in Gryffindor so well, too - i always thought that all of Neville's acts of courage were also suspiciously Slytherin; ie in Philosopher's Stone Neville stopping the Trio so that the house wouldn't lose points. btw - i happen to prefer silver. ^_~
Return to Top