Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Autumn Winds
tenken22
2009-04-04 . chapter 1
Nice hit. This little fic helps us see the inner workings of Saitou's mind well... Living for the fight and all...

Great!
hajimenokizu
2005-09-21 . chapter 1
This is a really great one shot!

I'm just a little bewildered on who the student is though... At first I thought it would be Yahiko... And it would be great but why am I thinking also of Sano... LOL! Great job for the wolf, he never would stop anyway.
EmptyWord
2004-06-13 . chapter 1
*beams* wonderful! My English teacher would be thrilled to see such work! And truthfully, I haven't seen this type of insightful writing since Steinbeck (though Steinbeck was a little more drawn-out). Also,I applaud you on your characterization of Saitou. Very very well done.

"It was not easy, these days, to find a death with honour in it."
TanukiGirl22
2004-03-30 . chapter 1
intersting, i'm not a big fan of saitou bit i do think that he's a great fighter and he hass a lot of history behind him, as well as the mysteries of his personality can be fascinating. i liked it, he was in kept character. hope to read more, keep writing! oh, and pls look at my fics
Gouki
2003-12-16 . chapter 1
I like it alot!!
But It's too bad there isn't alot of new stuff.
I would have liked a little bit more new story parts.
Seraph of Winters Past
2003-08-28 . chapter 1
Great story! I think you should make a sequel where Saitou trains *the student*, (who most people know to be Yahiko). Anyway, great job!
Gouki
2003-08-20 . chapter 1
I liked it alot thank you for the good read.
Shadowstar
2003-08-18 . chapter 1
I liked it too. Quite interesting and fun to read.
kamorgana
2003-08-18 . chapter 1
This must be one of the best portrayals of Saitoh that I've seen in a long time. I really like his views on Kenshin and the others, it's extremely in character. Congratulations, and thank you for the read!
Polka Dot
2003-08-18 . chapter 1
I;m a big s/S fan, but these were nice little introspective peices even without the romance.
Firuze Khanume
2003-08-18 . chapter 1
Though I think Saitou wouldn't kill the inhabitants of the dojo (not out of mercy but out of convenience. They weren't his targets). This is question of POV, and I respect yours.
Anyway, I really enjoyed your fic very much. This insight into Saitou's mind is deep and well done, very well written, with very interesting parallelisms and images. Really inspiring. Good to see good writers in fan fiction net for a change! (and three hurrahs when they write about one of my favorite 'bad boys'...
Clemen
2003-08-18 . chapter 1
Wow really great fic and very believebly.
Monou Hakkai
2003-08-18 . chapter 1
Great Saito fic. It's something I've never stumbled across occasionally around the Shinsen Gumi wolf man. I remember seeing this part of the manga quite well in my mind *all those cigarettes, man Saito scares me*. I think the characterisation here was realistic. Saito knows he won't be able to get his rematch with Battousai, seeing how things have changed, even he has moved on in life. My personal favourite line was "But in the end, though a wolf remained a wolf, and a Shinsengumi remained a Shinsengumi, a man-slayer could become a peaceful rurouni." The last sentence was really nice. Really REALLY nice. It just gave me this sudden reaction of thinking that this is the softer side of Saito. Well with the fugitive on the loose, looks like he could get another source of amusement ^_^. It's easy to imagine who he'll be going after now I guess.
EEevee
2003-08-17 . chapter 1
Very nice. a well done one-shot fic.
Return to Top