 TheSummoningDark 2007-10-17 . chapter 1Me again. Just rereading this, and I feel obliged to congratulate you again on this. Maybe you don't claim to be an authority, but I've lived my entire life in Scotland and it sounds about right to me. Just a few things:
-To me, Mac sounds more west coast than anything else; a little too thick for Glasgow, and /definitely/ not Edinburgh.
-I don't know what part of Scotland you know, but I'm not sure about the 'Jeenjeahr'. Around here it's be more like 'JINjur'
-The missing 't' is bloody murder to write, isn't it?
Peace out (An' a bonny day tae ye)
~TSD |
 freya 2006-05-28 . chapter 1 go you!
I hate it when people mangle scottish accents!
but i don't think mac's accent is from Edinburgh -we tend not to have a scottish accent - it tends towards an English accent here unfortunately |
 Dormantly banjkazfan 2006-04-30 . chapter 1*claps* I'm really pleased with this! :) I've never seen people make fun of Mac's accent, but I'm only reading the first page of fanfics...
But way to go! I'm scared to even try to type it...or any accent. |
 TheSummoningDark 2006-04-27 . chapter 1 Ah, I salute you. Being a proud Glaswegian myself, the mangled Scottish accents in this fandom offend me. Bravo...or 'gaun yersel, big man'... |
 Fiona Fargazer 2005-06-24 . chapter 1I love to listen to Scottish and Irish accents, I mean I watch that stupid little kid's show Piggly Winks on PBS kids just to listen to them talk, but I must admit that I could never write down how the accent is pronounced and after what I've heard here I doubt I'll ever try. I liked the new words at the bottom though. I've heard "ken" in the book Kidnapped when I read it for school and I love the "balaloo." Oh, and I really like Mac too. anyway I think this is probably the longest review I've ever written so I better just shutup now, huh.
~Fiona Fargazer~ |
 Nomia 2005-05-23 . chapter 1BRILLIANT!! ::claps enthusiastically:: it's about time someone put someting like this up. kudos!! |
 Magistrix Mundi 2005-01-29 . chapter 1 I agree that knowing about Scottish accents is necessary for writing Chicken Run stuff, but this isn't a fic. Maybe you should put this in an author's note in a fic. |
 nothernlight33 2004-08-20 . chapter 1Alright,I'm learning scottish already!HOORAY. |
 Belphegor 2004-05-02 . chapter 1Thanks for this "sort-of-rant", Fala :) I'm French, and I suppose my chances to hear a *real* Scottish accent in real life are as good as any American, so it's always a delight when a person sorts things out, accent-wise. (Don't know if that is a real expression, though.)
I'm a big fan of Mac's, too (hourray for DVDs with the original version :) and I can also understand the exasperation when an author mangles an accent you're familiar with and/or fond of. (And it just happens that I'm very fond of the Scottish accent; Scotland as I remember it [a one-week trip in high school] is a chillingly beautiful place, and I'm a big fan of John Hannah :o)
Anyway, I'll sure remember you if someday I come to write a story with a Scottish character - I promise I'll do everything to prevent accent abuse :o)
Much of love,
Belphegor :o] |
 Crystal Charmer 2003-09-30 . chapter 1The Scottish accent is cool...and yeah, I see what you mean sometimes in stories. :S I hate the way that they shorten "the" to "th". It really makes me mad. Anyway, it's good that you spoke out like this. Not only will it make people understand what they should be doing, but you may have also helped for other people's fanfics in the near future. :) |
 British Child 2003-09-29 . chapter 1Thanks for the advice! Will keep this in mind for my fanfic. Good on you! |
 smeagol 2003-08-30 . chapter 1 wow... I never thought someone would be so passionate about that... good for you mate!
although this isn't a story. |
 Crystal the Echidna 2003-08-23 . chapter 1 O.o; Meh, i hate the "Gingah" thing too. BTW, the CR fanfiction is dead here. Give or take a few updates once in a blue moon... |