 Siriusly Loopy 2008-01-09 . chapter 1Poor Remus. He'll join Sirius soon. *sob* And Tonks'll be there, too. |
 BlackHalliwell 2006-09-07 . chapter 1kool |
 orly 2004-11-13 . chapter 1this was really good. you kept them in character and made it believable. it was very sweet. i hope something like this happens in book 6! |
 Heathz 2004-07-20 . chapter 1brill so far i'm looking forward to an update |
 The Dark Horse 2004-07-01 . chapter 1That was really good. and the ending was funny! |
 walker-of-the-shadow-path 2004-05-13 . chapter 1I thought you were very true to canon in this, especially with the Dursleys. I thought it was a really, I dunno, tender (?) moment between the two of them when they stood there crying. Anyway I thought it was really good. |
 Mrs Moony 2004-04-09 . chapter 1Wonderful story! Harry and Remus are both very in character, and you've used their emotions well.
The ending was especially hilarious! :D
~MrsMoony |
 LAoR 2004-03-24 . chapter 1EXCELLENT ending! I absolutely loved it!! I couldn't help but laugh at the end, it was great. Anyway, yeah, this little bit was really really good! I'm going to check to see if you have anything else to read...hopefully you do. Dunno yet though, I haven't checked (obviously). Anyway (again) is this all you were planning on writing for this? If so, it's wonderful! lol It's really really great that you had Harry and Lupin like that...it was exactly how I imagined the two of them acting.
Great job!
much love,
from LAoR |
 Caramia S. Cesiyess 2003-09-22 . chapter 1Great job. Absolutely perfect!
Aww, I love Remus. He's awesome, and you did a fantastic job describing him. I think I'll have to read more of yoru stuff!
C~ |
 all who wander 2003-08-27 . chapter 1graet please update soon rach x |
 TiniTinuviel 2003-08-24 . chapter 1Very good! Lots of feeling behind it! Is there going to be more? *hopeful, hopeful, hopeful!* |
 Lisande 2003-08-23 . chapter 1That was really a great one!
I think the way Harry Lupin comforted each other is for both the best way to cope with Sirius's death.
I only can advise JKR to write a similar scene at the beginning of Book#6!
Great job, really.
Lisande |
 Jack Ichijouji 2003-08-22 . chapter 1I feel a warm drop of liquid rolling down my cheek...
Wait, that's sweat. Sacred HELL, it's hot.
Anyway, I... found it much better than mine. Nice to see them lean on each other. |
 Stinky Stan 2003-08-21 . chapter 1*sniff* You almost made me cry! I miss Sirius... *sniff* Ah, getting off track here... I really liked it! It seemed very realistic. |
 Twinnie 2003-08-21 . chapter 1I liked that one. The relationship between Harry and Lupin is interesting and realistic... And you have kept both of them in character. Good work!
Oh, by the way, ff.net says you don't accept anonymous reviews... Did you do that on purpose? Because a lot of people find it annoying to log in to review, and lots of other people don't have an identity to log into to begin with... |