 Linwe-the-elf 2005-04-23 . chapter 1*cries* PADFOOT!
Loved the poem. |
 The Fifth Marauder 2005-01-17 . chapter 1 It's so beautiful... but I wish that you didn't have to write it... because I wish he weren't dead! *Sob* Sirius was my favorite... |
 The Thief Kuronue 2004-08-25 . chapter 1...Wow...breathtaking! I write poetry myself and I feel inspired by this! Darn you and being great! Jk ^_^ Beautifully done! |
 A Thousand Paper Cranes 2004-07-23 . chapter 1I quite liked it. :) |
 Jeanne2 2004-02-04 . chapter 1*tear*
emotions running rampant
~SHE DIDN'T DO IT, SHE CAN'T HAVE DONE IT! WE WON'T STAND FOR IT, MS. ROWLING! *tear* Unless we - *sob* - _have_ to. . .
*bursts out crying. |
 deppyfan 2003-12-22 . chapter 1That was beautiful! |
 griefmourner 2003-10-18 . chapter 1 This is the best tribute I read so far.
Of course, Sirus is the brightest star. I wish somewhere could tell Harry, "Look! Your godfather never leaves you. He's up there, shining down on you. He still takes care of you, Harry."
A beautiful tribute. I'm sure Sirius would appreciate this. |
 Chess 2003-10-14 . chapter 1That was fantastic. My favorite part was the last stanza. I wrote a tribute for Sirius as well, if you want to check it out. |
 Shiera Abdon 2003-10-08 . chapter 1 Great Poem, so sad though. |
 I am a fanfiction critic 2003-09-14 . chapter 1That was beautifully written poem.
I heard Harry's voice reciting it or maybe even Remus Lupin's voice when I was reading it.
Good job! |
 Believe 2003-09-14 . chapter 1wow.
I can't say anything more, that was amazing, but so sad! You are so talented. |
 Junsui46319 2003-08-25 . chapter 1*whispers (i feel it is apropriate to whisper)* ohh poor sirius! its so sad. oh and poor harry! *hugs em both*
great poem! so sad... but thats how i write poems to. i cant right happy so theyre sad.
Caitlyn |
 Thranx 2003-08-25 . chapter 1Oh,that was so sweet, the contrast between light and dark (or black)...Ah, poor Harry...Poor Remus...Now write one about how sexy Snape is; school is starting again and I will need something to amuse myself! |
 Gusha 2003-08-25 . chapter 1Well then, until the last stanza it could have been Severus' poem.
I do not feel at all qualified to comment further. *wink* thought I would review anyway. |
 Tamsy 2003-08-24 . chapter 1 Wow! That is so good. You know, that is true. The last thing he saw...the black veil. The last thing he heard...Harry calling his name. You done good, girl! |