Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Old Weapons
Lamiel
2004-08-30 . chapter 1
This is beautiful. Such a lovely mix of introspection and imagery, and the description of the sky and cliffs and gulls is so perfect. The circling back at the end, to the gulls that "peck and play with the length of bowstring almost hidden amongst the grasses" - breath-taking. The symbolism is well balanced, strong without being overbearing. Lovely vignette. Thank you.
Marchwriter
2004-05-08 . chapter 1
That was lovely and so very poignant. I loved it and it goes on the favorite's list.
~Lady of Light~
Atiaran
2003-09-01 . chapter 1
Nice. Good last line.
The Lady Arianrod
2003-08-27 . chapter 1
Harrowingly empty and sad... and at the same moment breathtakingly beautiful... although Legolas is not one of my favorite characters, I truly felt the message that you wanted to put across... many people speak of how the Elves that did not leave Middle-earth would feel like, but your story is different. I truly sensed the emptiness in Legolas' heart as he finds himself to be worn and alone, with only the gulls and the sea... This is very forlorn and heart-wrenching, but it is perhaps one of the best stories I've read, for its descriptions and for its depressing, extremely powerful effect... and the ambiguous ending... great job.
regnum
2003-08-26 . chapter 1
i can just see this happening - great work! *^^*
Lady Jade
2003-08-26 . chapter 1
Oh my this is probably the best fanfiction I have ever read. You are a verry talented writter this is a verry well written story good work!
Return to Top