 Zippie 2007-09-21 . chapter 1Congratulations! You and your wonderful story have been inaugurated into the "Pirates of the Caribbean FanFiction Hall of Fame".
Please visit my profile page for more details.
It's not as grand as it sounds, but we hope that by gathering all the best stories in one place we will provide a valuable service for all PotC FanFiction lovers out there.
Please come and make some nominations of your own, share your writing wisdom or just join in the fun! |
 Jennifer Lynn Weston 2007-07-13 . chapter 26Very, very good fic! Loads of events, loads of variation, and I like this competant-but-not-overbearing version of Anamarie. |
 mypiratecat1 2007-03-03 . chapter 1The very first POTC fan fic that I ever read, a long time ago... and still one of my favorites! |
 Nora 2006-09-08 . chapter 1 This is one of the few fan fiction stories I actually enjoyed. Even though you ‘added’ your own voice to these characters you still kept a lot of their original ‘feel’ and that’s what really drew me in. Also the fact that you didn’t make Elizabeth into the evil witch lol
I hope you will write more some time. I read and enjoyed all your posts. |
 TITUS 2006-08-04 . chapter 9 Hello!
first of all: Thank you for such an amazing fiction! Today it's my 18.th birthday and yesterday I printed it so to say as a birthday present :)) *g*
It was a great birthday present!
I LOVED the part where Jack saves Norrington's life! That's just wonderful!
THANK YOU FOR THIS FANFICTION! |
 Skystrike26 2005-12-29 . chapter 26You are absolutely BRILLIANT! Your writing is enspiring. And the flawless portray of character through out the story... I absolutley loved it. I am greatly anticipating the continued posting of the sequel. Please do so soon! Chapter 10! |
 Captain Sarah Sparrow 2005-09-14 . chapter 26I only found this story after it was finished, but it was well worth the long hours reading it. I loved this story, there's so few out there that are able to have both Norrington and Jack together and keep them in-character, but you managed it perfectly. |
 CaptainTish 2004-09-30 . chapter 26Good story! Well-written, and it's obvious you did a fair amount of research to make it historically accurate. And nautically, and geographically, and militarily, and medically and so on. Good job! |
 CaptainTish 2004-09-29 . chapter 18Love how Jack pushed his way through the crowd and asked for his hat back. LOL! |
 CaptainTish 2004-09-28 . chapter 15How sad--people thinking Jack is dead! I like the little flashback to the part on the Interceptor during the movie -- nice touch. |
 CaptainTish 2004-09-28 . chapter 14Whew. Jack's okay. I was a little worried for a minute there. Just a tad. Good chapter! I like all the interaction between Jack and Anamaria. |
 CaptainTish 2004-09-20 . chapter 5Hello! Wow, it's been a long time since I reviewed this story. Sorry, I got distracted by other things. But tonight, I was looking for some good fanfic that is well-written, has Jack in-character, and no annoying Mary-Sue's, and well, your story fits all those criteria! Good job! |
 CaptainTish 2004-05-02 . chapter 4Good story. I like the description of Jack being pelted with questions from all the little kids. I can just see that! |
 Scarlett7 2004-04-22 . chapter 1This is just an all around fabulous story. Great plot, wonderful characterization, I love it. I sent you an e-mail a while ago telling you how impressed I was with your writing. At the time, I had only read bits and pieces of your story, but now I am reading the whole thing (I'm about half way through) and I am just totally loving every word of this. GREAT JOB!
Scarlett |
 ShanniC 2004-04-03 . chapter 26 I read this in one sitting... and I absolutely LOVED it! Where has this story been hiding? It's tucked away beneath a pile of Jack/Yous, and Will/OCs that I am SO glad I found this jewel. You have an amazing writing talent, but you already knew that didn't you? I also liked the historical fiction. (Hey if you like hostrocial fiction, check out 1921, by Morgan Llywelyn)You have done an excellent job on this fic. I can't wait for the sequel... There WILL be a sequel right? RIGHT? (*prays for a sequel*) I couldgo on about how much I liked this but, everyone else has already stated my sentiments. |