OMG! You made me cry that was so touching and well written! *Starts wacking herself over the head with the 3rd HP book(hard cover)* STOP. *wack* CRYING *wack* YOU *wack* EMOTIONAL *wack* FOOL *wack* !*WACK!* *knocks herself out trying to stop crying* ...@_@...

The ending was so touching! My heart was all tight! I cried! over a fanfic no less! Brilliant! :,D

this is a fabulous fanfiction. i can actually feel remus' stress to tell them, the shock and shame off of james and sirius. i also felt the surprise off of remus and james when sirius came up with their nicknames, and lastly, the sadness and anger for james and sirius at the end. i could feel all of those emotions, whether you planned it or not.
thank you-
agatha-christie fan-04

aww i was on the verge of crying while reading that!brilliant!

Very good

Oo! i like! i like Remus stories!

ohh...sooo good. Really sad, at hte end. I like it a lot a lot.

Wonderful! Truely spectacular! Ooh, I adore Remus!

Oh my golly gosh. That's one of my favourite songs and these are some of my favourite characters. In most circumstances, this would make me incredibly critical of any story involving these elements. But this was really, really good... I liked that you made the 'James and Sirius find out' scene a little more tense then most people's versions. Much good!

That was a really sweet fic, I read it because I was listening to the song at the time, and I was very glad. I loved the changes in perspective, you handled it well.

wow...that's really good. I love Remus stories! :)

That was really incredible. I got chills reading that last line.

Great job!

Great story.. it was really touching... write more... your an exlelent author.

WOW! That was a great great great great great great great... STORY! OHHHH I loved it! You are a very very good writer! If you don't mind I loved the story so much I put it in my favorites. I really liked how you made the story about Remus and the ending was sorta sad... but that was a very good ending. You really discribed a lot and I liked that! I think you will make a great MPP (yuck... Wormtail I don't think you should write about *die rat die*)!

Thank you for making a great story and making the reading more enjoyable! Happy Holidays! Happy New Year!

Love,

Lilli

P.S. I liked how you made it a song fic too!