Buh? Another Fan who likes Raoul, Hates E/C AND thinks that the Phantom went to heaven? WHA?
LOL
No, really I loved this, it was so sweet. (oh I'm a Carolatta fan too! >_

Unrealistic, yes... but, at the same time, oddly IC. I kept holding my breath, so it was definitely a good read, then. Thanks for sharing! :)

I can't BELIEVE I didn't review this before. What was I thinking? *smacks head* I didn't even see this phic--must've gotten buried under all the E/C garbage...I mean phics...oh, you know what I mean. LOL.

I LOVE this. Raoul was perfect, I loved his final conversation with Erik. *points* See, Raoul IS a good man! I was right! Thank you for writing him as such. I have a huge grin on my face...this is exactly how it should have ended.

Adios,

Meg

aww that fic was so sweet... i like it alot...

... ... maybe you can like... make erik not die and then him and raoul run off together and stuff... and christine dies or something...

lol jp...

write more PotO fics please @.@

Aw! That was very cute, although I don't believe Erik or Raoul would ever settle their differences so quickly... perhaps since Erik had nothing to lose and everything, but... at any rate... Very well-done. :D

You know, I normally can't stand these 'Erik and Raoul become friends' stories, because they tend to be cheesy, overdone, OOC, and poorly written. But this was pretty good... well written, but I felt you stayed in character. (but what's with him kissing Raoul's hand?:)

*cries eyes out* that is so sad... WAH!
Peaches: *tears up* poor Eriky...

::sniff:: I'm so glad there are actually people who don't hate Raoul. I like this story alot. I think Raoul definitely owed Erik some words of gratitude.

I'm back!

OOh, nice job! I love the pov here...kind of third person and first person mixed together. Me likee. Poor Erik! Ah! Great job with the cynical sarcasm...Erik is such a character, you portrayed him well!

hey sparrow, say 'jello' in spanish: '...hello...'

anyway, i still think htat you are implying slash. which is not necessarily a bad thing. ^_^ vive la slash!

also i don't think that Erik's bookshelf would be badly organised. i mean, he does spend most of his time in the house...don't you think he would organise a bookshelf at some point i his life?

anyway, bravo. ^_^

Oh, how cool! This is so cute. I'm so glad someone wrote a story where Raoul is neither a mindless, heartless jerk nor a silly idiot. This is just so cute! And you are such a wonderful person for not falling prey to Raoul-stereotyping. Bravo!

that was...erm...cheesy and pathetic. no offence. but- Erik and Raoul as friends? oh well, It was still written well!

Yey! Raoul and Erik make peace! But then Erik dies! *;_;* (I sort of liked it that Erik brought Raoul's hands to his lips. *is a shounen-ai fangirl* ^^;; )
Anyway, I liked it. Raoul isn't a bumbling idiot in this fic, rather a kind man who is willing to make friends with the man who tried to take his woman. ^^;;

~L-Gurl

*sniff* tha was so sad... and so beautiful... lovely! btw.. thanx 4 yur review!

~OGK

That was amazing. Very original, I don't think that I have ever read something like that! You also kept both Erik and Raoul in character! A very nice addition to the end. You should talk to Leroux