 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 13What is the use in writing an AU if you don't do something to change it. You started out well. I am disappointed with your decisions. I feel that under the circumstances you created they are invalid. Harry's life would change. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 11So Fudge was behind it. This I can believe. But Ms Watson would follow up on it. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 10Did Severus not talk to Ms Watson? I don't like it that she never gets peace. Someone that would bend wouldn't care that much. And no way would Social Services not find Harry being abused. They would investigate much more thoroughly. I believe you need to find out exactly what they do. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 9Harry would be better off with Severus than the Dursleys. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 8Hopefully things will get better. When you write an AU you need to adapt the characters actions to fit the scenario. Snape is in character but you are keeping him blind. He isn't. He didn't have much to do with Harry in the books. Here he lives next door. No matter how private he is he will hear Vernon yelling, see Harry in the garden and other things that don't work. He is intelligent enough to realize things don't add up. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 7Severus isn't that stupid. He can be blind but given the proximity of his location he will see what is going on. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 6Good! Somebody is paying attention! Didn't it occur to Ms Watson that Dudley's gang would back up any story he told? Are these people so inept that 'peer pressure' and bullying are something they aren't acquaitained with? |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 5Now I just hope this teacher follows up on the problem. They have access to records. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 4Good deal! I am enjoying this story. :) |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 3Good job here! However Severus should recognize fear when he sees it. He may think it is fear of him though but he is a very intelligent man. It won't take him long to see the fear of a hunted creature. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 2Hopefully Severus will actually see and observe not just look at Harry.
Really good chapter. But where was the schoolyard monitor? There is always at least one teacher on the playground so something like that can't happen. |
 Cassandra30 2009-07-04 . chapter 1Realistic beginning. Well written. Very in character. I like it. |
 Elfwyn 2009-02-14 . chapter 13Well I see no purpose to this story other than that the wizarding world set up and knowingly used Harry, a little boy, making them all just as bad as Voldemort. Snape was as blind as always and has no idea what child psychology means, let alone that his mission was to get inside the Dursley Household and he never did. He did see what was in front of his eyes making me wonder how he survived as a spy. He is also a man who should never had been a teacher as he lets his prejudices get the better of whatever logic he had. Dumbledore is the worst sort of user there is, while at least Fudge is just plain incompetent. |
 klm 2009-01-11 . chapter 13 Great start! will there be updates? |
 Octobergrl 2008-12-27 . chapter 13 I was disappointed. You created such an amazing story and then the last chapter ruined it! Why couldn't Snape save Harry!!??!! Why would he leave? Why wouldn't Harry recognize the man who cared for him!!?
You had the chance to write an amazing and original story and i think you threw it away...
Hopefully the sequel won't disappoint. |