Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Phoenix Tears Part 1 - Page 1 of 34
Ginnylove9990
2009-06-07 . chapter 28
This is one hell of a good story. I sorry I did not review before I was to hooked into this story. I had to finish this story. Now I am on to the next one. Please keep up the great work.
tar heels superstar
2008-08-28 . chapter 28
good chapter and update soon this is getting good.
teachergirl
2008-08-02 . chapter 28
I like your story, but your chapters are so short that some of the A/N are longer that the chapter. I can't wait the read the sequel.
munchnzoey
2007-10-25 . chapter 5
great story!
munchnzoey
2007-10-25 . chapter 6
great story!
munchnzoey
2007-10-25 . chapter 1
great story!!
radish
2007-08-28 . chapter 5
I think Dumbledore never really had any barriers with students. his relationship with Harry is different but I'm sure this is not the first time he's mentored a student.
radish
2007-08-28 . chapter 4
Dumbledore's not exactly sappy, just upset. I think he's more human than JKR lets on in the book and would feel pretty upset right now. I like Sirius' will but i think he would out something in there about Snape not bothering Harry anymore and given all grimmauld place's books to hermione. Good job!
breezer
2007-08-11 . chapter 28
Hey great story! I enjoyed the switching points of view, it made it more interesting! Well I'm going to go read the sequel!
Silver-WindScar
2007-07-11 . chapter 28
I don't have a fitting word for how...how..."wow" this story is. I hope I have some room in my favorites.

Your typing set up was a little wonky in the beginning, but it smoothed out into good paragraphs through the story. That's about the only wrong thing other than a few bits where I made a bit of sense by pushing the words around in the sentences. Pretty good!
Yelene-ryudream
2007-07-05 . chapter 28
This is an excellent story. The grammar could use a little work, but I have seen a lot worse.
Riker15
2007-05-19 . chapter 28
Awesome and I Love It!
LupinLover88
2007-04-03 . chapter 14
lol Yeah, I suspected something of that sort would happen, and I tried to suggest it in the chapter where Dumbledore left Kreature with Umbridge but the stupid thing wouldn't let me. lol Anyways, I'll read on.
LupinLover88
2007-04-03 . chapter 13
Oh goodness, now the adjreniline starts pumping in my blood. This is so much more like it!
LupinLover88
2007-04-03 . chapter 11
Okay, Harry was a bit out of character and Dumbledore slightly, very slightly. In Harry's eyes, Dumbledore's the wise old Headmaster. One who broke his trust, but still that wise old headmaster. He's not likely to swop jokes and stories with him. It just isn't likely. While Dumbledore's rather open and probably would tell the story, it's just not like Harry to do that. I don't know, it's just... sort of out of character in my oppinion. Otherwise, it's rather amusing.
Return to Top