Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Different Boy Who Lived - Page 1 of 8
JustWriter2
2008-05-08 . chapter 27
Sirius changing a diaper... (snickers)

I was hoping that you'd make Harry the one that talks to snakes, just to add a twist onto the theories of cannon characters about how Harry can speak Parseltongue. But you just reinforced their theories... (pouts)


-JW`chan ^-^
AnnF
2007-12-14 . chapter 27
Hope you get a chance to update soon.
chocoluvr
2006-11-22 . chapter 27
So did the older three children blackmail Sirus to let them stau up late or eat all of the sweets they wanted for their silence, and is that why Lily wouldn't let him babysit anymore.
RyanBrookes
2006-11-13 . chapter 26
I loved this chapter, like all the chapters that you do, but yet again I am reminded of the different views of characters. In my opinion, Hermione's parent's wouldn't keep a five year old from toys. I do agree with her parents teaching her how to read and write (I taught myself around that age), but even so. I love reading your fanfiction, and even though I would have done things differently, you are clearly one of the best writers I have seen. I await your next chapter.

As always

Ryan.
Jewel3
2006-11-13 . chapter 27
Aww, that was truly adorable. One thing I wanted to mention though, in your author notes, you said that the book was published in 1989, about a month before Hermione was born. Hermione was actually born in 1979 (Harry and Neville in 1980). I don't know if you just said that cuz of the canon for your story, but I thought I'd point it out, just in case. :)
AchillesMonkey
2006-11-13 . chapter 27
Wasn't Hermione born in 1979? Good chapter. Update soon!
Fugatad
2006-11-12 . chapter 6
It's a good story,but you need to make the chapters a little bit longer.
LegalAlien1
2006-11-12 . chapter 27
Great new chapter!

I had to laugh while imagining Sirius trying to change Heather's diapers - and failing at that. And then being corrected by a six year old! ROFL

Please write more soon!
Mistri Tonks' Admirer
2006-11-12 . chapter 27
Hmm... this was quite the interesting and believable chapter.

Hermione is quite lovely as the put out girl, but it's quite strange that she commands such power over the boys. Then again, she IS quite bossy... so it ain't that strange.

Lily should know better than to let Sirius babysit under any circumstance...
AnnF
2006-10-27 . chapter 26
poor hermione.
AnnF
2006-10-27 . chapter 24
:) Hermione
ChuckTheGingy
2006-09-02 . chapter 26
Yay! So I really like what you've written so far, you have a very fun-to-read writing style, almost no type-os, and the story itself is really good. Me gusta.

I'm really excited to see how this develops. Is this the new trio? No Ron? And how long do you plan on taking this? Through Hogwarts? That would be so much fun :)

Hope you write more soon!

Charlie
Nicole Black
2006-08-28 . chapter 26
Wow, great work, I loved yourstory I do hope you are going to write more.
Nik
Mistri Tonks' Admirer
2006-08-20 . chapter 26
I like this chapter. It expands so much on the Hermione we know, and it's all very believable, especially since JKR wanted to give Hermione a little sister but never did get around to it.

I hope things continue to improve for Hermione.
pstibbons
2006-08-20 . chapter 26
That was sweet - Hermione crying over her old doll (though I think a teddy would have been preferable), and her normally wanting/forced to be a grown-up. And her lying to authority figures starts early - great!
Return to Top