Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: What Really Happened
Taika
2004-06-27 . chapter 1
Interesting theory having Harry go back and save Snape. Although, I think James would say something when everyone commented on his heroic feat. Sadly, it suggests a more depressing look at James- less heroic and noble. Smiles, Taika
Feronia
2004-04-15 . chapter 1
Wow. I loved your "Notes" and "In Hiding" and "Psychological Telephone Counseling," as I've expressed in other reviews "), but this one is quite different and very interesting. I never considered this angle (or heard of it either). What if you're right? What if James was an arrogant jerk all his life? That would be quite appropriate, I think. And Harry would, I agree, be more likely to risk his life to save Snape than James would be. And I like the fact that you had Snape invent the Wolfsbane potion, and that you let him cry at the realization that his tormenters had actually tried to kill him. There aren't all that many times when it seems right to have Snape cry, but you judged it perfectly in making this one of them. I love your Snape stories! I plan to read "Oddball Pride," but I'm going to wait till I have time to sit and read all thirty+ chapter in one delicious Snapey gulp! Thanks for writing such great stories about the greatest character JKR has yet provided us with: Professor Severus Snape. Keep it up!
kiki
2003-12-27 . chapter 1
haha i can see that happening more so thn what jk wrote
ReeraTheRed
2003-10-27 . chapter 1
Very interesting, and no, I never thought of this at all, although it does make a lot of sense. Part of me wants a continuation of this (how would adult Snape feel if he found out it was Harry, not James, who saved his life - he'd probably resent Harry more than ever). But I can understand just leaving it as it is.
Nemo Returning
2003-10-23 . chapter 1
Why not :)
no one
2003-10-23 . chapter 1
oh.interesing.
Anora
2003-10-23 . chapter 1
Ah come on make Harry and Serverus friends- in the past... maybe Harry should get a new idenity or something... or a unregonizable charm. those things have worked for centurys. :D
JessicaKou
2003-10-23 . chapter 1
Very very interesting. It was a really nice story. I would like to see more! :) How about going on?
Jessica :)
Enahma
2003-10-23 . chapter 1
Oh, you are here again with a good one-shot!
I'm GLAD!
Enahma
Return to Top