..Interesting idea, perhaps you could lengthen the story ?

ay chica, this was tragic! but there was a hope at the end, and i quite liked it. there's so much emotion, the pain that poor remus must have been feeling...brilliance!

(p.s. - there are other good Christian songs out there haha)

~XM

Well I can't say that I find your comment incredibly pertinent to my story nor all that helpful but okay and thank you for noticing it's existance.
As for the very low and very self-righteous jab at my character, I have absolutely nothing against Christianity and very much regret I could never quite believe in it. Though I don't appreciate your audacity to actually look down on me. All the same, my opinion is that the large part of original Christian music is of a remarkably poor quality and that is my opinion, something that needs not be of any importance to much of anyone else, especially if they are upset by it. Even if that statement had been meant 100% seriously--which it was not, though I doubt you realized--I would not understand your strange choice to tell me off--in the politest, if snarky, of words.
Finally, please do not bother to review any more of my stories if you have nothing worthwhile to say. Nice isn't a requirement, but at least be correct and helpful.

I must say your summary rather put me off of reading this story. Your choice of words made you seem close-minded and prejudiced against Christianity. I'll have you know there is a lot of wonderful Christian music out there. No matter what type of music you want to listen to there are Christian groups to try. I feel terribly sorry for you if you haven't heard any of it. You really should give it a chance. God bless you! -Saravi

wow...simply wow! I love how you write, and I loved the main idea. *also a firm beleiver that Sirius is alive!*. For quite some time, I’ve been thinking of writing a fic about Lupin after the death of James and Sirius, but I guess I’d always get really depressed thinking about the idea so I kinda gave up. Anyways, I loved how you put the emotion into words, I’ve never heard the song, but it sounds good.

This is a cool beans song fic. I love the song Meant to Live, and I never realized that it could fit Remus Lupin. They were meant to live for so much more, SO WHY DID PETER RUIN IT!?!? Okay, calm down.

Wow. again. This is great! how does this only have, what, four reveiws? BLASPHEMY, I SAY! Anyway, great job. Sad, but great.
And yeah, we all know that Sirius isn't dead. J.K Rowling just said that so we would throw her books down and stomp on them. yep.

ooh, aah. i thought your portrayl was very accurate and well written too. Oh, and a sfor the only good christian song, look for the band Snax, they're the only christian rock bacnd I can stand, the religious stuff is more of an undertone and isn't so in your face. good fic though!

I really like this! Although Remus is clearly in total despair, i love the way that his idea that if he lives it keeps a little bit of James, Sirius and the Marauders alive too keeps him going. I also like the way that Peter isn't just a low-down, good-for-nothing snake. That portrail is just too 2D. Great work!

Aww...*sobs* I love you Remmy!! It's uber horrible how Remus is all alone now...DAMN YOU ROWLING!! DAMN YOU!!

Hey that was very good. I love how Remus is living so the Marauders still live on through him. It' s great. This makes you think. it's kind of insightful i guess. again, i loved it.