Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Stealing the Two Towers - Reviews: Page 1 of 13

samh;p8
2007-04-17
ch 14, anon.
abuseSWET!
Destroyer of the Elves
2007-01-16
ch 7,
abuseOh, man. These stories are great. It's about time someone took their egos down a few notches. But... a few things. Some are nitpicking, and some are real problems.

Nitpicking first: Use italics. Even if your computer can't handle it, the editor on can. Don't just use asterisks.

Now, the real problem: As much as I love these stories, you do have a big problem on your hands. Your characters are Mary Sues. Don't get me wrong, I know that this is a parody, but there is such thing as going too far. For example, fighting Aragorn in a dress while walking upstairs backwards and still beating him, while a funny image, is just not plausible. And domesticating a Warg isn't going to happen in the near future unless you have some very big doggie treats.

So, in conclusion, tone down the Mary Sue-ness a bit, fix some grammar and punctuation errors, and you'll have one heck of a parody series!

-Sincerely, Destroyer of the Elves
the lady in devils red
2006-07-04
ch 3,
abuseso funny, can you do more stories
MBDTA
2006-02-11
ch 14,
abuseGreat! I like Sam's POV!
MBDTA
2006-02-10
ch 13,
abuseLet the credits roll!
MBDTA
2006-02-10
ch 12,
abuseGeorge of the Jungle! Liked the hair knot!
MBDTA
2006-02-10
ch 11,
abuseNice reference to centrifugal force! Poor Cliffe! Her "child" doesn't love her!! Nice work! (BTW, you like blue glitter hairspray, don't you?)
MBDTA
2006-02-10
ch 10,
abuse"Hurl to flow"...that really got me! Great craziness...nothing in particular...all great and crazy!
MBDTA
2006-02-10
ch 9,
abuseThe talking through the metal objects is very creative! Seems like you learn some quite dangerous things in Aikido!! Great job!
MBDTA
2006-02-10
ch 8,
abuseLoved the domino effect!! That was utterly crazy...I always liked doing secret santa! Happy writing!
MBDTA
2006-02-05
ch 7,
abuseI like Cliffie! Is she big and red??
MBDTA
2006-02-05
ch 6,
abuseLovely!! Sounds like fun floating down a river in a bathing suit with the boom box cranking!!
MBDTA
2006-02-05
ch 5,
abuseCraziness!! Much better than the stupid half-time performance I'm watching out of the corner of my eye!! Loved the socks deal!! Great work!!
MBDTA
2006-02-05
ch 4,
abuseGreat! So out there, but 'tis still hilarious...Nice work!
MBDTA
2006-02-05
ch 3,
abuseWonderful!! Liked the walkie-talkies!!
Return to Top