Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Harry Potter and The Year Of the Quarrels - Page 1 of 35
Hahukum Konn
2009-08-03 . chapter 31
I remember this old fic! :) On the re-read it's been quite good but one niggling thing still stands out; WHY was Ginny dating Draco Malfoy, going so far as to use rude words to her friends, who, by the way, seem to have utterly forgotten what happened?

I guess the real answer to that will be in the sequel. Off I go :)
Sarquan
2008-10-05 . chapter 13
george is going to be captured bc one half cant stand without another, and i think either cho or luna is the other bc cho/harry's first kiss was under the mistletoe, and luna was always talking about nargles in the mistletoe. so ya. i guess i have to read to find out but i wanted to take a guess beforehand.:-)
ArgentRoseSableWolf
2008-10-01 . chapter 3
I'm afraid that you lost me at the end of chapter three. In my opinion, no post-Ootp fic that has Harry's Occlumency lessons continuing with Snivellus is remotely credible. At the end of book 5, Dumbledore himself admits that they were a mistake. Considering that Snape used them as nothing more than an attempt to torment Harry, expecting him to be willing to continue them with the greasy git just isn't believable.

It was interesting up to that point, but suspension of disbelief only goes so far. Also, the scene with Malfoy on the train looked like setting the stage for turning him good. Redeeming either Snape or Draco is a major strain on credibility, redeeming them both seems to be something far too many authors try to do. Again, just not something I can buy into. Neither of them to that point has shown any sign of being a decent human being, so trying to change them both doesn't really wash.

Sorry to sound so negative, but those are glaring inconsistencies in my view. Good luck with your work.

Wolf
jcv
2008-06-14 . chapter 31
dude this wasnt at all h/hr u suck
Jimbocous
2008-05-09 . chapter 31
Nicely done! Looking forward to the sequel. Thanks for an interesting, if sometimes surreal, read!
Kaze Kami
2008-04-26 . chapter 31
Brilliant story! Quite original and easily one of the best stories I have read in quite some time. Though there wasn't really any Harry Hermione romance, it was still very well written. Well done.
jagadeesanenator
2008-03-14 . chapter 31
Aw! That was good. Is hould have read this before the one about the darkest days but there both really good and I hope I can read the third one. Usually I read completeed ones because I get bored really easily having to wait for the chapters. But I'll try my best
jagadeesanenator
2008-03-14 . chapter 6
Hahaha, this cracked me up, though I think it was a mistake:
Parvati, her sister Patil,
jagadeesanenator
2008-03-13 . chapter 1
How come I cant really read the chapter? All it is are things like' ' ' '' ' ' ' ' '' '
Nicole Summer
2007-12-18 . chapter 31
that was AWSOME
Nicole Summer
2007-12-18 . chapter 21
this one was awsome
MiaStar
2007-04-30 . chapter 31
omg i luvved this! it is definitly JK worthy!

all i have to say is tat in the sequel, Harry better get w/ Ginny or Hermione, and tat Hermione is the cat, Ron in the dog, and Draco is the weasel!
Charlottex5494
2007-04-30 . chapter 15
Good Story!
Though I just wanted to point out that Rictusempra is the tickling charm. Furnunculus covers a person in boils when it is cast.
Sweet-Lemmon
2006-10-12 . chapter 31
Interesting but...where's the rest of it? What about Lupin? And better...where's HHr? This it under HHr, right?
xheartkreuzx
2006-09-03 . chapter 31
i absolutely loved it!
Return to Top