Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: No Longer Any Reason - Page 1 of 3
Ringelsocke
2008-01-06 . chapter 1
Oh, I like it!
Very well written! :-)
You really caught the moment!
Felarof
2005-05-17 . chapter 1
Very well written! I really liked it! It captured the spur of the moment very well!
ForeverFaramir
2004-12-24 . chapter 1
Oh, that wa so sad. I agree with your opinion of David Wenham's potrayal of Faramir, and I often did wonder what went through his mind as he rode across the Pelanor.

An excellent fic, superbly written.
Olivia
2004-09-23 . chapter 1
Beautiful! Just beautiful!
Rosie26
2004-09-04 . chapter 1
Powerful stuff. Brilliant portrayal of Faramir's emotions.
Shortnshort
2004-06-02 . chapter 1
great Story
Ecri
2004-02-15 . chapter 1
Wow! Brilliant! I agree with you completely about David Wenham's potrayal of Faramir, and you were certainly true to that portrayal here! You captured Faramir's despair, his longing to see his brother, and the desolation he must have felt in that moment when he was convinced that Denethor did not love him in the slightest.
Wonderful!
Campy Capybara
2004-01-28 . chapter 1
*tears...sniff* Lovely, lovely, lovely!
You have captured the essence of Faramir's charge; that hopelessness, that despair, that meek submission to orders, despite knowing that his father was sending him to his doom.
Excellently done!
Catmint
2004-01-28 . chapter 1
Wow. This is incredibly painful to read - in a good sense. You've captured Faramir's pain fantastically. You made me cry. David Wenham certainly had a lot to do with that - I honestly don't think anybody could have played Faramir better, having seen T and RotK. This is an outstanding piece of writing.
Anastasia Who
2004-01-10 . chapter 1
*sniff* *wipes away tears* This is so good. I know what you mean by tearing when hearing the song on the soundtrack. This was a great story. Poor Faramir.
Patty
2004-01-09 . chapter 1
Thank goodness I've found someone else who is as smitten with Faramir as I. This is a great story! I certainly hope you'll write on more
incidents in Faramir's life.
Don't wait for the extended cut of the movie. Grab a copy of the book and base a story on his stay in the House of Healing!! In other words,
I WANT MORE FROM YOU ON FARAMIR.
Aurora West
2004-01-05 . chapter 1
Another lovely Faramir story by you. You for him very well. So I hope that you soon write another story about him.
Erestor
2004-01-03 . chapter 1
I guess Faramir didn't have much to live for, but he had a lot to die for.
~
Very touching story. I liked it, and I loved your portrayal of Faramir. Very good.
~
According to what I've heard, there should be lots more Faramir in the Extended Version of RotK. I hope you're inspired to write more stories like this one.
RavenMerc
2004-01-02 . chapter 1
Lovely, but heart-breaking story. I think you captured Faramir's frame of mind perfectly, his intent to return on his shield, as it were. Especially after getting no quarter from his father. *sniffle* please keep up the good work!
Evendim
2004-01-01 . chapter 1
Finally a review! Sorry, but I got hung up with your Christmas and New Year stories! I loved this! Bravo! You captured the ache in Faramir's heart at losing his beloved brother and where is the comfort from their cold blooded father? Stuck in Amazon no doubt!The pathos is beautiful and the characterisations as good as I have come to expect from your work! Only complaint I do have is that there is so little of it, but I know you are having problems with an injured arm so...sigh!...I forgive you!Keep up the good work! I adore your writing and I am not easily pleased!How about a try at the Houses of Healing scene? To tide us poor bereft fans over until PeeJay gets his act together? He's not REALLY God, he just thinks he is! (This from some twit who actually visited NZ to check out the locations!) I hope he pays back all our loyalty! Nice one, Adalanta, contact you soon! OOh and thanks for the dedication, I was really, really honoured!I am adding you to my favourite author and favourite story list! Hugs honey! Evendim
Return to Top