Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Gondor's grief
parazesis 2008-07-13 . chapter 1
Wow that's sad yet incredibly similar to what I would imagen happening. Good Job.
AgentRusco 2006-01-02 . chapter 1
i like this. (at this point rusco learns that she has been reviewing in a very unorganized and rather uncouth manner.) Anyway. Yeh. I like Boromir. It irks me that people make him out to be the bad guy. (rants a bit. like when ranting about people putting Edmund down...)
Anna Denethorion 2005-10-10 . chapter 1
Wow. You're good. I'm stupid at poetry.
Tasari 2004-10-19 . chapter 1
Weep, aye, for Boromir. Honorable warrior tempted and redeemed. Honor to him ever through this song.
Wurd 2004-03-28 . chapter 1
Alas, for Boromir! Too misunderstood by too many fans, a gallant, noble, great man fallen to a temptation brought by desperation. ^_^ I was always a big fan of Boromir's, and it's good to find something like this. Though I don't think he was intended to have a love left behind (although Tolkien did originally plan for him to be betrothed to a daughter of Theoden's) it's always nice to wonder, and the poem is quite good. You can feel the sorrow. I take it you were likely a great fan of the steward's son. I know I wet several pages of novel when he died. Great work!
boz4PM 2003-12-27 . chapter 1
Thanks for that, and your positive feedback. Most kind. Please do have a look at the other two poems I've posted and let me know what you think - good or bad. I have just started posting a fanfic story too to which the other two poems are related, if you are interested. :)
Fangelir 2003-12-27 . chapter 1
Very touching. Nice job. :)
Return to Top