This is one of the best stories I've read. It sounds very realistic and is written skillfully. A real good job!

Really good.

Personaly I found the chapters a little long, other than that perfect!

I didn't notice Salogel was Legolas backwards- duh!


Lindale

Oh...my...Lord...

This story is amazing. It truly is a work of art. I loved it, you did an excellent job. This is one of the best stories I have read, you write beautifully, and the plot was wonderful. Kudos to you, this is fantastic.

Great Job,

Bambii

This was a good story - I started 2 read it because it only had 4 chapters. Boy, was I surprised when I found out how long it was! It's very good though. It drags in some parts, but even I have to admit some scenery description is neccessary. Good read!

i'm one of the fastest readers in my class...but this took me 30 min. ^.^ i have to say, though, this is very nicely developed. i LOVE the humor! ^.^ ja ne!

I'm so glad you reposted this is less chapters. It made it much easier to read.

Where on earth do you get these ideas? They're brilliant! All those twists and turns! I love that you have a "deleted" scene section. I could honestly see the whole thing being played out in front of me. Lovely.

*whacks head against wall* I'm so stupid. Salogel, Legolas, Duh. Took Me forever to get that.*whacks head agianst wall some more* All you did was spell Legolas backwards, and I didn't get it till just now. Okay then. I really liked this story. Twas very good.

I just finished reading your story. It was really great, and like a novel. I just wonder what happened to the stable boy (I forgot his name) who freed Jarinel...

The story is really great and well thought of, with a great plot. And I think that it is very good that they decided that peace is better without the stone...

Beautiful, stunning, inspirational! That's still not enough to accurately describe this wonderful story. I remember reading the first few chapters of the original version a while ago but circumstances have meant that I've only recently been able to return to it. I'm so glad I have not been dissapointed, as this is an exceptional piece of work. I've been a fan of your writing for some time and I hope to read more in the future.

This is a very good story. It is well written.

Ooh I read this before! Girl, this story was totally AWESOME! I remember reading it last fall. I can't wait to move on to the sequel! ;)

very nice story, it's amazingly long. keep up the good work!!

Holy. Chapters take forever to load! Nice, though.
I really really wish you'd write some more in the LotR fandom. Sequel, or anything else, but you're just so good at it!
Keep it up!

Hey! Just re-read this story, and wanted to let you know that I loved it. The characters had great interactions, and your plot was amazing. Great Job! Maybe, hopefully, maybe you are working on something else or planning for something else in the near future?

*applauds* Bravo! I never read the original, but this was great! It took me almost two hours to get through it, which is really long for me! I love it! I hate fics that are just pointless Leggy torture, but you did it with STYLE!!